Page 10 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 10

E x c lus iv e  I nt er v iew



              Only 43% of surveyed jurisdictions have developed   provide essential services or pursue clearly de ned                                       Any decision should therefore be based on the    appropriate arrangements in place to preserve
              a government-wide ownership policy, while only    public policy objectives. The critical issue is how that                                    enterprise’s  mandate,   performance,   market   essential services.  This approach can also give
              42%   report   functional  separation  between    support is designed and disclosed.  The OECD                                                conditions,  scal implications and the availability of   prospective  investors  greater  clarity  over
              ownership and policymaking       or   regulatory   Guidelines call for SOEs’ economic activities to                                           alternative mechanisms for delivering the public   commercial objectives, liabilities and the respective
              responsibilities.                                 operate on a level playing  eld with private                                                policy objective, rather than on short-term  scal   roles of the state and the SOE.
                                                                competitors. This means avoiding ownership-based                                            considerations alone.
              The OECD Guidelines on Corporate Governance of    regulatory or tax advantages, ensuring  nancing is                                                                                           ICMA:    How     can   Pakistan—and      similar
              State-Owned Enterprises (“OECD Guidelines”)       consistent with market principles for commercial                                            Good corporate governance can also contribute to   developing  economies    undergoing    active
              therefore emphasise a clear allocation  of        activities, making state support transparent, and                                           broader development objectives, including capital   economic restructuring — e ectively institutionalize
              responsibilities and, as far as possible, separation of   clearly identifying the costs associated with public                                market development, by creating an enabling      competitive neutrality, robust anti-corruption
              the state’s ownership function from functions that   service obligations. Separate accounting for                                             environment for SOEs to access market-based      integrity frameworks, and independent external
              could a ect market conditions.  Where complete    commercial and public-service activities, coupled                                            nancing, alongside wider e orts to strengthen the   audit practices (such as mandatory audit  rm
              institutional  separation  is  not  feasible,  clear   with compensation proportionate to the cost of                                         capital market ecosystem.                        rotation) to build investor trust and ensure a
              mandates, internal separation and independent     ful lling those public service obligations, is                                              ICMA: In emerging market economies like          level playing  eld?
              regulatory functions can provide important        particularly important in reducing the risk of                                              Pakistan, where  scal de cits are tightly linked   Carmine Di Noia: Investor con dence depends not
              safeguards.                                                                                                                                   to   loss-making   commercial    SOEs,    what   only on the ownership model, but on whether SOEs
                                                                distortive cross-subsidisation. The objective is not to
                                                                                                                                                                                              would
                                                                                                                                                                                                       you
              At enterprise level, professional and transparent   prevent legitimate public intervention, but to                                            immediate    sequencing   steps  from   ad-hoc   operate within credible, transparent and predictable
                                                                                                                                                                          to
                                                                                                                                                                               transition
                                                                                                                                                            recommend
                                                                                                                                                                                                             governance  frameworks.  The OECD  framework
              board    nomination    processes,   appropriate   ensure that it is transparent, proportionate and does                                       administrative  bailouts   to  a   centralized,  points to three mutually reinforcing priorities:
              competency and independence requirements,         not unnecessarily distort competition.                                                      professionalized   ownership     policy   that   applying   comparable   legal  and    regulatory
              con ict-of-interest safeguards and su cient board   ICMA: In light of shifting global macroeconomic                                           successfully attracts private capital through    conditions to SOEs and private  rms where they
              authority and autonomy are equally important in   pressures, what criteria should guide a                                                     privatization without disrupting essential public   undertake economic activities; embedding integrity
              enabling boards to exercise objective judgement   government's decision  to  pursue  full-scale                                               service obligations?                             through     risk-based   compliance    systems,
              and limiting undue political in uence.
                                                                privatization versus retaining state ownership                                              Carmine Di Noia: For Pakistan, as for any economy   con ict-of-interest  safeguards,  whistleblower
              ICMA:  When statutory exemptions or indirect      through structured capital frameworks and                                                   undertaking signi cant SOE reform, sequencing    protection    and    transparent,   merit-based
 ICMA: Given that global SOEs command a   Governments can strengthen capital discipline by   state support soften hard budget constraints for   performance-based management?  matters and reforms need to re ect national   appointments; and subjecting SOEs to high-quality
 massive footprint of USD 141 trillion in assets yet   setting clear commercial and non-commercial   commercial SOEs, how can international                                                                  independent    external  audit  and   disclosure
 lag behind private peers in pro tability and carry   objectives,  monitoring  performance  against  Carmine Di Noia: I would say that what matters is      circumstances and public-service requirements. A   standards.
 higher leverage, what policy instruments should   measurable  targets,  establishing  appropriate  standards better enforce competitive neutrality   whether there is a clear and transparent rationale for   sound starting point is to establish the rationale for
 ownership entities deploy to enforce capital   rate-of-return expectations where relevant, and   to ensure private market competitors are not   state ownership.   state ownership of each enterprise and distinguish   The 2026 evidence shows that independent external
 discipline and bridge this performance gap   adopting dividend policies that take account of   disadvantaged?                                              commercial   activities  from  public   service  audit is already widespread internationally, with
 without compromising essential public policy   investment needs,  nancial sustainability and an   Governments should periodically assess whether           obligations. This can support the development of a   93% of surveyed jurisdictions applying it to some or
 mandate?  appropriate capital structure.   Carmine Di Noia: There can be legitimate reasons   ownership continues to serve an identi able public           coherent ownership policy, clearer allocation of   all SOEs, while a majority also require audit- rm
 Carmine Di Noia: State-owned enterprises play a   Crucially, public service obligations should be   for governments to support SOEs or other market   interest, such as delivering essential services,   ownership  responsibilities,  and  stronger  rotation.  Rotation  can  reinforce  auditor
 major role in the global economy. According to our   clearly identi ed, transparently costed and   participants, particularly when they are required to
 latest OECD report Ownership and Governance of   adequately compensated, so that boards and   addressing market failures, safeguarding strategic           portfolio-level monitoring and reporting.        independence, but it should form part of a broader
 ownership entities can distinguish the cost of
 State-Owned Enterprises 2026, their economic   achieving public policy objectives from underlying   interests or managing  critical                        Once these foundations are in place, governments   system that includes strong audit committees,
 footprint  has  doubled  over  the  past decade,  so   commercial performance.  infrastructure, and whether state                                                                                           internal controls,  transparent  nancial reporting
 ensuring they are well governed is increasingly                               ownership is the most e ective                                               are  better  positioned  to assess enterprise by   and e ective follow-up on audit  ndings. For
 important.   ICMA:  With less than half of surveyed                           way of achieving that objective.                                             enterprise  whether   restructuring,  continued  Pakistan and other reforming economies, building
 consolidated
 jurisdictions
 maintaining
 a
 Pro tability alone is not a su cient measure of SOE   ownership policy and only 42% achieving a strict                                                     ownership, private participation or divestment   these elements consistently across commercially
 performance, because many SOEs are also expected   functional separation between ownership,   Where ownership is retained, the                             o ers the best long-term outcome, while putting   signi cant SOEs can help strengthen accountability,
 to deliver essential services or other public policy   policymaking,  and  regulation,  how  can  focus should be on professional                                                                           improve the credibility of  nancial information and
 objectives.  That said, the OECD’s latest evidence   governments e ectively mitigate con icts of   governance, clear performance
 shows  that,  across  the  six  industries  examined   interest and protect SOE boards from undue                                                                                                           create a more predictable environment for private
 (energy,  nance, transport, telecommunications,   political in uence?         expectations, appropriate capital                                                                                             investment.
 manufacturing and other utilities), SOEs have on   Carmine Di Noia: There has been meaningful progress   structures and e ective boards.
 average been less pro table and more leveraged   in professionalising state ownership, but the evidence   Where the original rationale no
 than comparable private  rms, which reinforces the   also shows scope  to strengthen  institutional   longer  applies,  divestment,
 importance of active and professional state   arrangements further.
 ownership.                                                                    including partial privatisation, can
                                                                               be  considered alongside other
                                                                               options.
                                                             ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026  5
   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15