Page 13 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 13

E x c lus iv e  I nt er v iew



              Ultimately,  the  question  is:  what  role  does  the   ICMA:  The Privatisation Commission has                                              The objective is to allocate each risk to the party   System  Average  Interruption  Frequency  Index                                     Muhammad Ali:  The Rs. 832.8 billion losses in
              State need to retain, what risks should it carry, and   received 10 EOIs for IESCO, with investors                                            best able to manage it. The investor should bear   (SAIFI), outage response, time, restoration time                                       FY2024–25 and the Rs. 6.563 trillion accumulated
              where can private-sector participation deliver    seeking between 51%   and 100% ownership                                                    operational, e ciency and commercial risks,      and  voltage  quality  should  form  part  of  the                                       losses explain why the programme cannot wait.
              better value and better outcomes?                 together with management control. Given the                                                 while the regulatory framework should provide    regulatory performance contract. Consumers                                               They set the urgency, but they should not be the
              ICMA: Pakistan has recently engaged with          strong response, what does the investor                                                     reasonable predictability and protect consumers.  should be able to see whether service quality is                                        only criterion for sequencing. A heavy loss-maker
              global     nancial    institutions   including    interest  tell  you  about  the  commercial                                                 So, PC would interpret the strong EOI response as   actually improving.                                                                   is not necessarily a saleable asset, and a
              BlackRock, J.P. Morgan, Citi, Barclays and        potential of Pakistan's power-distribution                                                  con dence in the underlying commercial           Fourth, investment. Privatisation should bring                                           transaction  launched before it  is ready tends to
              Rothschild  &  Co,  while  55  global  investment   sector,  and  what  concerns  do  investors                                               opportunity, provided that the transaction is    new investment into the distribution network,                                            fail or fetch a poor price. Experience shows that
              funds also participated in meetings with          continue to raise during due diligence?                                                     accompanied by a credible regulatory and market   particularly in grid modernisation, automation,                                         delays come mainly from market conditions,
              Pakistan's delegation at the J.P.  Morgan                                                                                                     reform framework.                                smart metering, system reinforcement and                                                 political transitions, exchange-rate volatility and   Muhammad Ali:  The state is moving from
              Emerging and Frontier Markets Opportunities       Muhammad Ali: Investors see commercial                                                                                                       technologies that reduce losses and improve                                              court  challenges,  not  from the  process  itself.   operator to regulator, facilitator and enabler. This
              Conference.    How    do    you   assess   the    potential in Pakistan's electricity distribution                                            ICMA: IESCO, FESCO and GEPCO collectively        reliability. But investment obligations should be                                        Earlier phases also stalled where balance sheets   has created value only if the entities and the
              signi cance of this renewed institutional         sector when the business is properly structured                                             serve more than 14 million consumers, making     linked to outputs and outcomes, rather than                                              were not cleaned up before bidding, labour        economy perform better afterwards, so the
              interest, and what must Pakistan do to convert    and professionally managed.  Ten expression of                                              DISCO privatisation not  simply  a   nancial     simply requiring investors to spend a certain                                            concerns were not addressed, and regulatory       measures to be tracked against baselines to 2030
              investor engagement into actual long-term         interests (EOIs), with investors considering                                                transaction but a major public-service reform.   amount of money.  This avoids unnecessary or                                             gaps remained. Sequencing therefore requires      may include:
              investment    and    successful   privatisation   ownership levels from 51% to 100% along with                                                What performance obligations should be built     in ated capital expenditure.                                                             consideration of several factors, including:      •  SOE losses and government support: Lower
              transactions?                                     management control, show that this is not merely                                            into the post-privatisation framework to                                                                                                  • Readiness: Legal clearances, restructuring,        annual losses, and lower budgetary transfers,

              Muhammad Ali: The interest from BlackRock, J.P.   an interest in acquiring an asset, it is an interest in                                     ensure that investors are accountable for loss   Fifth, customer service.  There should be                                                   treatment of legacy liabilities, and the labour   subsidies and guarantees. Fiscal space freed
                                                                                                                                                                                                             measurable standards for new connections,
              Morgan, Citi, Barclays and Rothschild, and the 55   operating and transforming the business.                                                  reduction, recovery, reliability, investment and   complaint resolution, billing accuracy, call centre                                       position.                                         up should be redirected to health, education
              funds that met our delegation, re ects improved   There are several reasons for that interest. IESCO                                          customer service?                                response, outage communication and consumer                                              •  Sector rules: Proceeds depend heavily on          and climate resilience.
              con dence in Pakistan's stabilisation and reform   has  a  large  and diversi ed customer  base,                                              Muhammad Ali: Privatisation Commission (PC)      grievance redressal.                                                                        tari s,  licensing   conditions   and    the   •  Private investment: New private investment
              direction. Interest alone does not bring capital, so   established infrastructure, a signi cant electricity                                   fully agrees that, with  more  than 14 million                                                                                               competition framework after sale.  Where          in the sectors where SOEs have been divested.
              the focus is on delivery. The completed transfers                                                                                             consumers across IESCO, FESCO and GEPCO, this    The important point is that these should not be                                             these reforms are a prerequisite, they come
              of PIA and First  Women Bank, and the three       market and relatively stronger operational                                                  cannot be treated simply as a  nancial           aspirational targets. They should be incorporated                                            rst.                                          • Productivity: Output per employee and asset
              DISCOs now in the market with bidders             fundamentals compared with many other DISCOs.                                               transaction. The real test of privatisation will be   into the regulatory framework with transparent                                                                                           utilization: For DISCOs, this could include
              conducting due diligence, are the proof investors   More importantly, there is considerable value                                             whether consumers  receive better and more       monitoring,      incentives    for     genuine                                           •  Market appetite: Capital market transactions      reductions in technical and commercial losses
              look for. Converting interest into investment rests   creation potential through loss reduction, better                                       reliable service.                                outperformance and meaningful penalties for                                                 and smaller deals can close in 4 - 8 months,      and better recoveries.
              on some critical elements, including the          customer service, technology, metering and                                                                                                   persistent underperformance.                                                                and major strategic sales take 12–18 months.
 ICMA: Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) and   an asset  can be commercially  operated with   following:  investment in the network. In other words,       Therefore,  ownership     change    must    be                                                                                               Early closures build credibility for the harder   •  Service quality: In the case of DISCOs, fewer
 outright privatisation involve fundamentally   private investment over a de ned period while   investors are not only looking at today's  nancial          accompanied by a clear, measurable and           At the same time, PC should avoid designing a                                               ones.                                             outages and delays, better coverage, and
 di erent risk and ownership structures. What   ownership remains with the State, a concession   • Policy   continuity:  The  privatisation                                                                  framework  that  transfers  all  risk  back  to  the                                     •  Fiscal drain:  The size of the drain on the       fewer consumer complaints.
 decision framework should policymakers use   may be appropriate.  Where a project requires   programme must stay on course across   performance;  they  are also  looking at what  the   enforceable performance framework. To achieve   government. A private investor should earn better              budget decides how fast the larger, more
 to determine whether a project is better suited   signi cant  private  capital,  expertise  and  political transitions. The SOE Act, 2023 and the   business  could  become  under  better  this, the Privatisation Commission would focus on   returns by becoming more e cient, not by                complex entities are moved.                    •  Capital markets: More listings and secondary
 to a PPP, concession, management contract, or   long-term performance, a PPP can be considered,   2024–2029  roadmap  give  investors  a  management.       ve areas.                                       receiving guaranteed returns regardless of                                                                                                    o erings, a wider free  oat, and a broader
 full privatisation?  with  risks allocated  to the  party  best  able  to   predictable pipeline.  The due diligence of IESCO has started, all ten         First, loss reduction.  The investor should have   performance.                                                                           The programme is already following this              investor base.
 manage them.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         approach. PIA and First Women Bank have been
 Muhammad Ali: I think the starting point should   •  Market-ready transactions: Restructuring,   national and international Interested Parties have        clearly de ned annual targets for technical and   Ultimately, the principle is simple: the investor                                                                                         •  Regulation and governance: Independent
 be the nature of the asset, the role the State needs   Privatisation becomes relevant where there is no   clean titles and settled sector rules must be in   been pre-quali ed. However, during  the market   commercial losses, with a credible baseline and a   should have the freedom to manage the business,   transferred to the successful buyers. Three DISCOs   regulators including NEPRA, CAA, SBP, OGRA,
 to retain, and where the private sector can create   compelling reason for the State to remain the   place before the launch of transactions.  sounding and roadshows, local and international   mechanism to reward outperformance and   but that freedom must come with accountability             are already in the market, and more DISCOs are in    PTA and CCP enforce the rules. Boards
 the greatest value. Public-Private Partnerships   owner and the enterprise can operate e ectively   investors asked about tari  and regulatory             penalise persistent underperformance.            for measurable outcomes. The consumer should                                             the pipeline.                                        appointed professionally and monitored
 (PPPs) concessions, management contracts and   in a competitive and appropriately regulated   •  Market sounding: It is mandatory before any   certainty, the treatment of legacy liabilities and                                                                                                    ICMA: Pakistan is attempting to shift the role       under the SOE Act 2023.
 privatisation are di erent  tools and  the right   market.  transaction goes to market, so that structures                                                 Second, recovery and commercial discipline.      see the bene t through lower losses, better                                              of the state from being a direct operator of
 choice  depends  on  the  circumstances  and   match what investors will actually bid for.  circular debt, uniform tari  arrangements,                     Recovery  should  improve  through better        reliability, improved service and a more                                                 commercial assets toward that of a regulator,     •  Wider economy: Foreign Direct Investment
 objectives of each project.  The  assessment should also  consider value  for   subsidy mechanisms, regulatory capacity, future                            metering, billing, collection, disconnection     responsive distribution company.                                                                                                              (FDI) in ows, integration of logistics, aviation
 money,  scal implications, market appetite,   •  Regional and economic stability: Investors   market  opening,  quality  and  reliability                  management and reduction of theft. However,                                                                                               facilitator and enabler of private investment.       and energy into global supply chains, and
 The  rst question is whether the State needs to   a ordability, regulatory capacity and the   price in currency, interest rate and security   obligations, and the extent of commercial and   the investor should not simply be rewarded for   ICMA: Pakistan's federal SOEs recorded Rs.            Looking ahead to 2030, what measurable               export competitiveness.
 retain ownership. Where ownership is important   long-term allocation of risk. The objective is not to   risks before they bid. A stable exchange rate,   regulatory risks that will ultimately sit with the   passing higher costs or tari s to consumers. The   832.8 billion in losses in FY2024–25, while   changes in SOE losses, government support,
 for strategic, public-service or regulatory reasons,   favour PPPs or privatisation as a matter  of   lower in ation and interest rates, and a calm                                                         accumulated losses to amounted to around Rs.                                             private investment, productivity, service
 forms of private-sector participation may be more   preference, but to match the structure to the   regional environment lower the risk premium   investor.  emphasis should be on operational improvement   6.563 trillion. How should these numbers
 appropriate than outright privatisation. If the   asset, the public policy objective and the capacity   and support better valuations. A stable   These are legitimate concerns. Privatisation   and e cient collection.  in uence the sequencing of the government's                                quality and capital-market participation
 principal challenge is operational performance, a   of the market to deliver.  macroeconomic,  political  and  security  Commission’s objective is not to remove every risk   Third, reliability and quality of supply. Key   27-transaction privatisation programme, and                            would demonstrate that this transition has
 management contract may be su cient. Where   environment must therefore be ensured and   from the investor, as that would defeat the                       Performance Indicators (KPIs) such as System     should  scal cost be the primary criterion for                                           genuinely created economic value rather than
                 sustained.                                     purpose of privatisation.                                                                   Average  Interruption  Duration  Index  (SAIDI),   deciding which entities are prioritised?                                               simply transferred ownership?

               8    ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16   17   18