Page 18 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 18

F oc us  S ec t ion



                         Table 1: Fiscal Exposure of the Federal SOE Portfolio, FY 2025                                                                    Smart meters reduce dependence on manual readings   The experience of Delhi o ers a useful comparative                                      The potential  nancial gains are particularly signi cant   are  held  accountable  for  acting  on  the  information                         Expand Smart Metering: Extend AMI beyond the      fo
                                                                                                                                                                                                             example. Tata Power Delhi Distribution Limited (Tata
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    existing 2.1 million installations, prioritising fee
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      en
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       in two areas such as power distribution and public
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         they provide.  The Cabinet Committee on SOEs has
                                                                                                                                                           and estimated billing while providing interval-based
                 Indicator                                            FY2025                                                                               consumption data accessible remotely (APP, 2026a).   Power-DDL), a distribution company privatised in                                       procurement. National Electric Power Regulatory   already emphasised  the need for  realistic  business                                      with the highest transmission and distribution losse
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Integrate metering with automated billing and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      re
                                                                                                                                                                                                             2002, reported reducing its aggregate technical and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         plans and hard budget constraints for chronically
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Authority (NEPRA) 2026, estimates that excess
                                                                                                                                                           Similarly, online ticketing creates a traceable record of
                 Aggregate revenue                                    About Rs 12.4 trillion                                                               tickets sold, while EPADS enables registered suppliers   commercial (AT&C) losses to 5.54% in FY2024–25. This                               transmission and distribution losses cost Rs 265 billion   loss-making enterprises (Business Recorder, 2026).                                revenue recovery systems.
                 Government  scal support to SOEs                     Rs 2,078 billion                                                                     to  compete  through  a  centralised  procurement   improvement was supported by an integrated                                              in FY2024–25. Even a modest reduction in these losses   Digital performance indicators must therefore be                                     Integrate SOE Procurement into EPADS:  Extend     Re

                 In ows from SOEs to government                       Rs 2,119 billion                                                                     platform.  With approximately 43,000 registered   approach combining smart metering, GIS-based asset                                        through AI-enabled anomaly detection and targeted   linked to managerial responsibility and measurable                                       mandatory  e-procurement across  SOEs  through    •
                 Total SOE debt                                       Rs 9.57 trillion                                                                     suppliers, the platform expands digital participation in   mapping and changes in ownership and management                                  inspections could translate into substantial  nancial   outcomes.                                                                            integration with the Electronic Public Procurement
 Introduction  SOE  losses  are                                                                                                                            public procurement, while the revised procurement   structures (Tata Power-DDL, n.d.). The broader lesson is                                savings. Similarly, procurement analytics o ers                                                                                              Acquisition and Disposal System (EPADS).  The
 concentrated  in  a  Unfunded pension liabilities                    About Rs 2 trillion                                                                                                                    that technology  delivers  meaningful operational                                                                                           Cybersecurity and Data Protection: The integration                                         government has informed the IMF of its plan to
 Pakistan’s federal state-owned enterprises (SOEs)   relatively small number   Guarantees and other contingencies   Rs 2.16 trillion                       rules make e-procurement mandatory (PPRA, 2026). In   improvements when supported by clear institutional                                    considerable potential because it can be introduced   of smart meters, digital ticketing platforms,                                          integrate EPADS with public-sector enterprises by Ju
 generated approximately Rs 12.4 trillion in revenue in   of entities, particularly in                                                                     each case, transactions that previously depended   responsibility,  e ective  management    and                                             without major additional hardware investment. EPADS   procurement systems and  nancial databases                                             2027 (The News, 2026). Implementation should begin
 FY2025 but ended the year with a net loss of Rs 122.9   the power distribution   Source: Finance Division (2026).                                         heavily  on  individual  record-keeping  become  more   accountability for measurable outcomes. Digitalization                              already generates digital tender and transaction   increases  the exposure  of  critical infrastructure  to                                  without waiting for the deadline.                 •
 billion, highlighting a signi cant gap between their   and transport sectors   Similarly,  the  International  Monetary  Fund  (IMF)'s   Act, 2025, establishes a framework for a national digital   transparent, traceable and accessible for independent   can provide the tools for better performance, but   records that can be analysed to identify unusual   cyberattacks and data breaches. Robust cybersecurity                           Pilot AI Applications with Measurable Returns:

 scale of operations and  nancial performance.   (Business  Recorder,  Governance and Corruption Diagnostic for Pakistan   masterplan, while the National AI Policy 2025 sets a   veri cation.               governance determines whether those tools translate                                       bidding   patterns,  price  deviations,  supplier  protocols, access controls and data protection                                            Prioritise  two or three applications addressing   •
 According to the Finance Division’s Central Monitoring   2026). In both sectors,   identi es weaknesses in SOE oversight and public   target  of  developing one million AI-trained   However, these developments should not be   into results.                                                       concentration   and    potential  procurement     mechanisms are essential to safeguarding these                                             identi able  nancial losses, particularly electricit

 Unit (CMU), pro ts of pro table SOEs declined by 13   operational ine ciencies   procurement as  areas that expose the  country to   professionals by 2030 (PID, 2025; Pro t, 2025).   interpreted  as evidence that  technology  alone  can   Where Arti cial Intelligence Can Add                   irregularities. This provides an opportunity to move   systems.  These requirements are also recognised in                                   detection, predictive maintenance and procurement
 percent to Rs 709.9 billion, while losses of loss-making   are closely linked  to   corruption risks (IMF, 2025). The report recommends   Together, these initiatives provide an institutional and   resolve institutional and operational weaknesses.                                                beyond     transaction   digitisation  towards    Pakistan's National AI Policy 2025 (MoITT, 2025).                                          analytics. Establish baseline indicators to assess a
 SOEs  eased  by  only  2  percent  to  Rs  832.8  billion   weaknesses in information   mandatory e-procurement across all public-sector   technological foundation for integrating digitalization   Digital systems can improve information availability   Value?                                    intelligence-driven procurement oversight.        Implementation   Costs,  Skills  and   Vendor                                              savings and operational improvements.             •
 (Finance Division, 2026; Business Recorder, 2026).   management, monitoring   transactions  and  the  elimination  of  procurement   and AI into SOE governance,  nancial monitoring and   and process e ciency, but their e ectiveness   Arti cial intelligence (AI) can create value in SOEs                                                          Dependence:    Digital  transformation  requires                                           Incorporate Digital  Targets into Management

 Consequently, the net loss was four times higher than   and  accountability.  preferences for SOEs. These measures underscore the   operational decision-making.  ultimately depends on implementation, institutional   where substantial volumes of transactional and                                                                                  substantial investment  in infrastructure, technical                                       Evaluation: Include measurable digital transformatio
 a year earlier (Figure 1), underscoring the need for   These include electricity   importance of digital systems in strengthening   Existing Digital Initiatives: Progress   ownership and accountability for results. For instance,   operational  data  are  already being generated  and                                                             expertise and workforce development. Pakistan's                                            targets in SOE business plans, Statements of Corpora
 stronger  nancial measurement, transparency and   supplied  but  not  transparency, improving procurement e ciency and                                    the increase in Pakistan Railways' revenue provides an   where ine ciencies, revenue leakages or operational                                                                                  smart-metering programme has experienced delays                                            Intent and CEO performance contracts. The CMU and
 oversight. This article examines how digitalization and   accurately metered, bills issued but not recovered, and   reducing opportunities for discretionary practices.  and Early Results  indication of improved  nancial performance, but it   losses follow identi able patterns. For example,                                                      arising from procurement and implementation                                                respective boards should periodically evaluate

 arti cial intelligence (AI) can help narrow this gap by   physical assets owned but inadequately tracked. The   Pakistan’s existing legal and policy framework provides   Four ongoing initiatives demonstrate measurable   does not, by itself, establish how much of the   existing smart-metering systems in Pakistan can  ag                        challenges, illustrating the risks associated with                                         progress against these targets.                   •
 improving  data  reliability, streamlining  digital   National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA,   a foundation for this transition. The SOE (Governance   progress in the digital transformation of Pakistan’s SOE   improvement can be attributed to digitalization.   irregularities such as meter tampering, faulty meters                technology selection and vendor management.                                                Management accountants have an important role in
 processes and strengthening board-level and   2026)  estimates  that  excess  transmission  and   and Operations) Act, 2023, and the SOE Ownership and   sector (Table 2).  Similarly, the smart-metering  programme,  initiated   and missing readings through rule-based monitoring                                                                   Furthermore, the transition must account for                                               implementing this roadmap.  Their responsibilities
 ownership oversight.  distribution losses cost Rs 265 billion in FY2024–25,   Management  Policy,  2023,  provide  for  the                               following the approval of an Asian Development Bank   (APP, 2026a). Building on these  capabilities, machine                                                                                                                                                                             should include evaluating the  nancial viability of
 while under-recovery of electricity bills resulted in an   establishment of the Central Monitoring Unit (CMU),   Although, these initiatives operate through di erent   loan in 2015, experienced delays of nearly two years   learning can analyse historical and real-time data to                                                                    workforce implications, particularly in SOEs with
 additional loss of more than Rs 132 billion.  which has subsequently developed a digital database   mechanisms, they share a common principle: replacing   amid disagreements over technology selection and   identify  more  complex  anomalies,  anticipate                                                                                           signi cant  unfunded  pension  obligations  of                                             technology investments, monitoring realised bene ts
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    and ensuring adequate internal controls over

 Strengthening SOE Governance   of SOE  nancial information aligned with International   fragmented, manual and individually controlled                    the bidding process (Express  Tribune, 2017).  This   equipment  failures  and  support  predictive                                                                                           approximately Rs 2 trillion. Reskilling programmes and                                     automated processes. This would help connect digital
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         structured workforce transition plans are therefore
                                                                processes with digital systems that generate veri able

 Through Digital Oversight and Policy   Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) (Business   records.                                                          illustrates how procurement challenges, institutional   decision-making.  Table 3 maps  ve potential AI                                     The sequencing of this transformation is critical. AI   necessary to ensure that technological improvements                                  expenditure with measurable organisational value.
               Recorder, 2026). Further, the Digital Nation Pakistan
                                                                                                                                                                                                             applications to the major sources of operational and
                                                                                                                                                           coordination and implementation delays can constrain

 Alignment                                                                                                                                                 the bene ts of technological investments.          nancial losses in Pakistan’s SOE sector.                                                 systems are only as reliable as the data on which they   do not create additional institutional and  nancial                                 Conclusion: Turning Digitalization into           •
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       are trained. Algorithms developed using estimated
 The Organization for Economic Co-operation and   Table 2: Digital initiatives in Pakistan's SOE Sector                                                                                                                                                                                                meter readings, incomplete transaction records or   pressures.                                                                               Financial Performance

 Development  (OECD)'s  revised Guidelines  on   Initiative   Entity     Reported evidence                                                                                                                                                                                                             unaudited  nancial statements risk reproducing    Weak Data Quality and Unexplained AI Models: AI                                            Digitalization and arti cial intelligence will not,
 Corporate Governance of State-Owned Enterprises call                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  existing  inaccuracies at  scale  and  generating   systems cannot produce reliable results when trained                                     themselves, determine whether Pakistan's SOEs should
 on governments to act as active, informed and   Advanced Metering   Power   2,125,296 smart meters installed by 5                                                                                                                                                                                     misleading insights.  Therefore, each layer of the   on incomplete, inaccurate or inconsistent data.                                         remain under public ownership or undergo

 professional owners while ensuring that SOEs adhere   Infrastructure (AMI)   Distribution   August 2026, including 1.15 million in                                                                                                                                                                    framework presented in Figure 2 depends on the    Similarly, decisions generated by algorithms must be                                       restructuring  or  privatisation.  Their  primary  •
 to high standards of transparency, accountability and   Companies   IESCO                                                                                                                                                                                                                             e ective implementation of the preceding layer.   explainable and open to scrutiny. Boards and auditors                                      contribution is to provide the government with
 disclosure (OECD, 2024). However, e ective ownership   (DISCOs)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Reliable data, standardised digital processes and   should understand the criteria behind  ags relating to                                   reliable  information  on  enterprise  costs,  reven
 oversight depends on the availability of timely, reliable                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               electricity consumers, suppliers or procurement bids,                                      operational ine ciencies and  nancial risks, thereby
 The balance sheet reveals greater  scal risks than the   and comparable information. Governments cannot   RABTA E-ticketing   Pakistan Railways   Revenue increased by 20% to Rs 115                                                                                                                  robust governance arrangements must be established   while internal audit functions should independently                                     strengthening the evidence base for ownership and
 income statement alone suggests (Table 1).   exercise informed oversight when enterprise data are   and Digital Payments   billion in FY2025–26. ERP integration,                                                                                                                                     before AI can deliver meaningful improvements in SOE   test automated systems as part of the organisation's                                  reform decisions.

 Government  scal support to SOEs amounted to Rs.   delayed, unaudited or presented in incompatible   real-time train tracking and digital                                                                                                                                                             performance.                                      broader internal control framework.                                                                                                          •
 2,078 billion in FY2025, almost matching the Rs. 2,119   formats.  freight booking are also included in the                                                                                                                                                                                           Risks and Preconditions for Successful                                                                                                       With loss-making SOEs reporting aggregate losses of
 billion received by the government from SOEs in the   The  World Bank (2023), in a study covering 76,000   reform roadmap.                                                                                                                                                                                                                              A Five-Step Roadmap                                                                        Rs 832.8 billion in FY2025, even modest improvements
 form of dividends, taxes and interest. This re ects the   state-owned  rms across 91 countries, found that their                                                                                                                                                                                      Digital Transformation                            To translate existing digital initiatives into measurable                                  in revenue recovery, procurement e ciency and asset
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    utilisation could generate substantial  scal bene ts
 scale of the government's  nancial exposure,   combined revenues averaged 17 percent of GDP, with   EPADS, -  PPRA and   526,271 transactions worth Rs 1,408.58                                                                                                                                       Despite the potential bene ts of digitalization and AI,   improvements in SOE performance, Pakistan should                                   However, success should be measured not by the
 particularly when considered alongside total SOE debt   nearly 70 percent operating in competitive markets.   E-Procurement  Procuring   billion processed in FY2024–25, with                                                                                                                         several risks could turn technology investments into   adopt the following priorities:                                                       amount invested in technology but by the resulting

 of Rs 9.57 trillion, unfunded pension liabilities of   Among  its   ve recommendations, the  World  Bank   Agencies   9,846 agencies registered.                                                                                                                                                      additional cost centres without delivering meaningful                                                                                        improvements   in    nancial  and   operational
 approximately Rs. 2 trillion, and guarantees and other   identi es nationwide mapping of state-owned                                                                                                                                                                                                  improvements in SOE performance. Four challenges   Strengthen  Data  and    Reporting  Systems:                                              performance.
 contingent liabilities of Rs. 2.16 trillion. Such   businesses as a priority. This highlights that e ective   SOE Digital Database   Central   Consolidated IFRS-aligned  nancial                                                                                                                     require particular attention:                     Implement integrated ERP systems and complete
 substantial  nancial obligations mean that  nancial   SOE reform begins with establishing a comprehensive   Monitoring Unit   data, with SOEs classi ed as green,                                                                                                                                     Technology   Without   Accountability:  Digital   IFRS-aligned  nancial reporting across commercial                                          Pakistan's priority should be to move from fragmente
 distress within an individual SOE can ultimately   and reliable information base, making data collection   (CMU), Finance   amber or red according to their                                                                                                                                           dashboards and automated reporting systems cannot   SOEs.  Automate  the submission  of  nancial  and                                        digital initiatives towards an integrated system of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    reliable data, automated processes, intelligent
 translate into additional pressure on the federal   and consolidation a prerequisite for informed   Division    nancial sustainability.                                                                                                                                                               improve performance unless boards and management   operational data to the CMU database to facilitate                                        analytics  and  accountable  governance.  The
 budget.  policymaking.  Source: Compiled by the author from the sources cited in the table.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             timely monitoring and risk identi cation.
                                                             ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026  13
   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23