Page 35 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 35

F oc us  S ec t ion



                                           Table 1: The Three Cases at A Glance                                                                                                                              in operational and commercial decisions should be                                         Fund  according to  performance- Public funding   justi ed by demonstrable progress rather than
                                                                                                                                                                                                             minimized.  When government ministers in uence
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         historical allocations or institutional precedent.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       should  be  linked to approved  business plans,
                                                         Core problem
                 Enterprise
                                  Latest reported  gure
                                                                                    Priority action
                Enterprise       Latest reported  gure   Core problem              Priority action                                                                                                           executive appointments  or  day-to-day business                                           measurable performance targets, and periodic      Conclusion: Stop Financing the
                                                                                                                                                                                                             decisions,  establishing  e ective  accountability                                        independent scrutiny. This is particularly important for
                                  A bid of PKR 135 billion
                 Pakistan
                                                         Ownership has changed, but a
                                                                                    Monitor operating cash  ows,
                Pakistan         A bid of PKR 135 billion   Ownership has changed, but a   Monitor operating cash  ows,                                                                                      becomes  considerably  more  di cult.  I  recommend                                       SOEs, where recurring  nancial support without    Problem, Start Funding the Solution
                 International
                                  for a 75% stake, against a
                                                                                    on-time performance, and
                                                         sustainable operational
                International    for a 75% stake, against a   sustainable operational   on-time performance, and
                 Airlines (PIA)
                Airlines (PIA)   reference price of PKR 100   turnaround is yet to be   progress towards operational                                                                                         empowering independent and professionally quali ed                                        corresponding operational improvements can turn   Pakistan’s SOE challenges are not simply a question of
                                                                                    progress towards operational
                                  reference price of PKR 100  turnaround is yet to be
                                  billion
                                                         demonstrated
                                                                                    and  nancial sustainability
                                 billion                demonstrated               and  nancial sustainability                                                                                               directors  to  manage  enterprises  on  commercial                                        temporary  scal assistance into a permanent liability.  privatization  versus  nationalization;  they  are
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         fundamentally about governance, accountability, and
                                                                                                                                                                                                             principles, report to the government, and remain
 Introduction  them up?  Some SOEs   Pakistan Steel   Cumulative losses of PKR   Operations have remained   Make a time-bound decision                                                                       accountable for performance and the responsible                                           Turning the Ship Around: A Roadmap                the e ective use of public resources. PIA will provide
                 Pakistan Steel
                                  Cumulative losses of PKR
                                                                                    Make a time-bound decision
                                                         Operations have remained
                                                                                    to revive, restructure, or exit,
                 Mills
                                  79.3 billion over three
                                                         suspended since 2015, while
 provide essential public   Mills   79.3 billion over three   suspended since 2015, while   to revive, restructure, or exit,                                                                                 stewardship of public assets.                                                             for Reform                                        an important test of whether a change in ownership
 State-owned enterprises (SOEs) were established to   services that the private   years, of which 72%   costs continue to accumulate   based on a transparent                                                                                                                                                                                            and professional management can restore the
                                  years, of which 72%
                                                         costs continue to accumulate
                                                                                    based on a transparent
 serve  the  public  interest,  yet  many  have  become  a   sector may be unwilling   comprised interest   feasibility assessment                                                                           This is not to suggest that government employees are                                      The proposed reform framework consists of  ve     commercial performance of a major enterprise.
                                  comprised interest
                                                                                    feasibility assessment
 signi cant  scal burden. According to the FY2025   or unable to deliver, and   expenses                                                                                                                     inherently ine ective or lack integrity. Rather,                                          phases, with each  SOE  placed  at the stage  most   Pakistan Steel Mills will test the government’s ability to
                                  expenses
 Federal SOE Report, loss-making enterprises incurred   the public may be   Pakistan Railways   Net loss of PKR 61.19   Commercial operations and   Introduce route-wise costing   From a management accounting perspective, I would   institutional arrangements can encourage risk aversion          appropriate to its circumstances. Under this      make timely, evidence-based decisions about an asset
                 Pakistan Railways
                                                         Commercial operations and
                                                                                    Introduce route-wise costing
                                  Net loss of PKR 61.19
 losses of PKR 832.8 billion, while the overall portfolio   willing to accept lower   billion against grants of   public-service obligations are   and transparent funding for   recommend  ve measures to improve the  nancial   and discourage individuals from taking responsibility                framework, PIA would be at Phase 4, with an emphasis   that has remained unproductive for years. Pakistan
                                  billion against grants of
                                                         public-service obligations are
                                                                                    and transparent funding for
 recorded an adjusted net loss of PKR 122.9 billion.   service  quality  in  PKR 64.03 billion in   not clearly separated in   public-service obligations   performance of Pakistan Railways:                for decisions that might a ect their tenure.                                              on enhanced performance monitoring; Pakistan Steel   Railways, meanwhile, will demonstrate whether
                                                         not clearly separated in
                                                                                    public-service obligations
                                  PKR 64.03 billion in
 Using PIA, Pakistan Steel Mills, and Pakistan Railways as   exchange for continued   FY2024–25    nancial reporting                                      1.  Route and service pro tability: Measure revenue   Consequently, appointments and decision-making                                         Mills would be at Phase 2, where the appropriate   stronger commercial discipline can be achieved while
                                  FY2024–25
                                                          nancial reporting
 examples, this article argues that repeated bailouts or   access to these services.                                                                         and avoidable costs by route and service category   may become oriented towards preserving the status                                     ownership and restructuring model must be         ful lling essential public-service obligations.
 changes in ownership, without adequate scrutiny and   The challenge, therefore,                                                                             to determine which services should be retained,   quo rather than addressing persistent commercial                                        determined; and Pakistan Railways would require   Above all, meaningful reform requires professionally
 accountability, are insu cient to achieve sustainable   is  to  distinguish  In my view, cash  ow from operations should be the   demand. Based on this  assessment, a clear  decision   modi ed, or discontinued.  weaknesses. Governance structures should encourage                                measures spanning Phases 1 to 3, covering diagnosis,   quali ed and independent directors who have the
 reform.  Instead,  SOE  transformation  requires  between costs arising   primary  indicator  of  PIA’s performance.  Although   should be made on whether to revitalize, restructure,   2.  Public-service funding: Identify and quantify the   responsible decision-making, reward performance,     the selection of an appropriate management model,   authority to make di cult decisions and the
 transparent management accounting practices,   from the provision of   pro tability can be in uenced by operating leverage   or close the enterprise. If revival is considered viable, it   costs of essential public services separately to   and protect SOE managers from undue political          and implementation of operational reforms.        accountability to deliver results.
 comprehensive   nancial  restructuring,  professional   public  goods and those   and  one-o   gains  or  losses,  operating  cash   ow   should be supported by a credible business plan and a   establish a transparent and informative subsidy   interference.                                     Phase 1-Diagnose: Conduct independent  nancial,   An enterprise cannot be considered successful merely
                                                                realistic  nancing strategy, potentially involving
 governance, and clearly de ned performance targets   resulting  from  operational  ine ciencies  and  provides a more direct indication of the airline’s ability   negotiations with creditors to restructure outstanding   requirement.  Ultimately, people and their potential are among an         operational, and governance reviews, focusing on   because it reports an accounting pro t. Its
               to  generate  cash  from  its  core business.  If  operating
 backed by accountability.  The article proposes a   mismanagement.  As  demonstrated  in Table  1  below,   cash  ow does not improve within the  rst year under   loans or, where feasible, secure debt relief. If no viable   enterprise’s most valuable assets. In my experience,                  commercial viability, strategic  importance,  and   performance must also demonstrate value for money,
 framework that distinguishes between commercially   management accounting plays a critical role in making   the new management, the e ectiveness of the   restructuring or revival option exists, alternative uses   3.  Asset and maintenance management: Plan major   family-owned businesses can bene t from a stronger   public-service obligations. Identify key employees    nancial sustainability, and, where applicable, the
 viable enterprises, strategically important entities, and   this distinction and informing evidence-based   turnaround  strategy  and  the credibility of  other   for the assets or an orderly closure should be   maintenance activities on a rolling-stock lifecycle   sense  of  ownership  and  accountability  than   whose experience and institutional knowledge are   e ective delivery of public services. The objective of
 those ful lling public-service obligations, with tailored   decisions about the future of SOEs.  reported performance improvements should be   considered. Public funds  should not continue  to   basis, prioritizing safety, cost-e ciency, and service   enterprises managed through distant government   essential to the enterprise’s future.      SOE reform should therefore be not only to stop the
 reform measures for each category. Ultimately,   carefully reassessed.   nance an enterprise without a credible path to                                     reliability.                                    hierarchies. SOE directors should identify key                                            Phase 2- Choose the model: Based on the diagnostic   persistent out ow of public funds but also to unlock
 sustainable  improvement  depends  on  capable,   PIA: Privatization Proceeds, but Will it    nancial viability or a clearly de ned exit strategy.       4.  Procurement and internal controls:  Promote    personnel, consult them on policy and commercial                                           ndings, adopt an appropriate approach for each SOE.   economic value and redirect resources towards
 independent leadership and a governance culture in   Deliver?  Pakistan Steel Mills: Time to Say   The experience of the former Sidex steelworks in         competition in procurement, strengthen contract   matters, and give serious consideration to their                                        Options may include private-sector participation for   activities that generate lasting economic and social
 which decision-makers are held accountable for their   Goodbye?  Gala i,  Romania,  o ers  a  useful,  though  not  directly                                oversight  and  internal  audits,  and  ensure that   concerns and  recommendations.  These employees                                     commercial enterprises, professional management   bene ts.
 decisions.  PIA is the most recent example of an SOE in which a   comparable, lesson. Its modernization, e ciency                                           identi ed control weaknesses are addressed.                                                                                                                                                 References
 change in ownership is expected to address recurring   Pakistan Steel Mills has remained closed since June                                                                                                  possess valuable institutional knowledge and have a                                       and  restructuring  for  businesses  with  turnaround
 From Fiscal Liability to Economic   de cits.  In  September 2026,  the  National  Assembly   2015. Figures published by the Ministry of Industries in   improvements, and working capital optimization were   5. Performance   reporting:  Report  monthly  direct stake in the enterprise’s success. Their insights   potential, and clearly de ned public-service contracts   •   Government of Pakistan, Finance Division. Federal State-Owned
 Contribution  Standing Committee on Privatization reported that a   September  2026  highlight  the  substantial   nancial   linked to speci c milestones established by the   performance indicators on a per-passenger and   can be more practical and valuable than those of                       for enterprises providing essential services.         EnterprisesAnnual  Aggregate  Report  FY2025.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             https://www. nance.gov.pk/publications/fed_soes_ann_agg_report_
                                                                European Bank for Reconstruction and Development
 consortium led by Arif Habib Corporation had bid PKR   burden associated with retaining the enterprise on the                                               per-tonne basis, alongside punctuality and safety   external advisers, including myself.                                                  Phase 3-Deliver: Address budgetary and commercial     2025.pdf
 The losses recorded in FY2025 were lower than the   135 billion for a 75% stake in PIA, against a reference   government’s books. Between FY2023–24 and   (EBRD).  The European Commission subsequently   metrics, to assess progress  against  targets and                                           liabilities, strengthen operating cost systems, and   •   National Assembly of Pakistan. Standing Committee of the National
 peak of PKR 851.4 billion reported in FY2024, which   price of PKR 100 billion. Management control had   FY2025–26,  the  mill  accumulated  losses  of  PKR  79.3   concluded that most of the indicators relating to   strengthen accountability.  What Management Accounting Can                   invest in infrastructure where economically justi ed.   Assembly  on  Privatization  meets.  17  September  2026.
 may appear encouraging at  rst glance. However, the   reportedly been transferred following the  initial   billion, of which PKR 57.4 billion represented interest   improved viability and productivity had been met.   Bring to the Table?                                                          Introduce   disciplined  procurement,   nancial   •   https://www.na.gov.pk/en/pressrelease_detail.php?id=8073
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Daily Independent. Pakistan Steel Mills incurs Rs79.3 billion loss in three
 pro t of PKR 709.9 billion in FY2025 was insu cient to    nancial closing in June 2026.  on loans.  Loan disbursements, grants, and audits were tied to an   Governance and People: The Final                                                                                                         reporting, and performance management. Establish      years  despite  remaining  closed.  24  September  2026.
 o set these losses, leaving a net adjusted loss of PKR   While the new management has the potential to turn   My recommendation is to adopt a time-bound,   approved operational programme, illustrating the   Frontier  Know  the real  costs-  By adopting activity-based                           independent, professionally quali ed boards with      https://www.dailyindependent.com.pk/2026/09/24/pakistan-steel-mill
 122.9 billion. The more complex question concerns the   PIA around, a change in ownership alone does not   evidence-based approach to determining the future of   importance of linking  nancial support to measurable   costing, SOEs can move beyond broad, accrual-based                           clear authority over commercial decisions and         s-incurs-rs79-3-billion-loss-in-three-years-despite-remaining-closed/
                                                                performance targets and veri able progress.
 appropriate course of action: should the state retain   guarantee improved performance. At least three   Pakistan Steel Mills, focusing on its assets, liabilities,   Although the performance of SOEs is often assessed in   cost  accounting  towards  a  more  detailed                            accountability for results.                       •   European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. Mittal Steel Gala i:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Project
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Summary
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Document.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    https://www.ebrd.com/home/
 and reform these enterprises, privatize them, or wind   and  commercial  potential.  An  independent  Pakistan Railways: Costs, Pro ts, and                nancial terms, personnel and governance policies are   understanding of cost drivers and resource                                                                                                work-with-us/projects/psd/27928.html
 lessons can be drawn from the PIA experience. First,   assessment of the mill’s viability should be conducted,                                            frequently  underlying  causes   of    nancial    consumption. This would  help management identify                                         Phase 4-Monitor and report: Publish regular       •   European Commission. Third Monitoring Report on Steel Restructuring
 ownership  change  should  be  accompanied  by   taking into account its physical assets, workforce   Public Services                                     underperformance. In my experience, some SOE      ine ciencies, allocate resources more e ectively, and                                     performance   scorecards  covering  commercial        in  Romania.  2010.  https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN
 operational reforms to improve route pro tability,   capabilities,   nancial  position,  and  potential  market   The FY2024–25 loss of PKR 61.19 billion was recorded   directors and executive managers lack the professional   evaluate the costs of individual products, services, and            outcomes,  nancial sustainability, and public-service   /TXT/?qid=1789170156418&uri=CELEX%3A52010DC0476
 revenue yield, aircraft utilization, maintenance               against total revenue and other income of PKR 92.72                                        competence, con dence, or authority needed to take   operations.                                                                            objectives. These reports should demonstrate progress   •   Dawn. Railways losses swell to Rs61bn. 28 June 2026.
 e ciency, fuel e ciency, and crew productivity.   Figure 2. Interest accounted for approximately 72% of Pakistan Steel Mills’   billion. During the same period, the federal                                                                                                                          against measurable targets and assess whether public   https://www.dawn.com/news/2011249/railways-losses-swell-to-rs61bn
 Second, legacy liabilities should be clearly identi ed   reported cumulative losses over the three-year period.  government provided PKR 64.03 billion in revenue   responsibility for di cult commercial decisions.   Budget, forecast, and explain variances- SOEs                                  resources are generating value for money.         •   Dawn. Railways in loss despite record revenues. 7 July 2026.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             https://www.dawn.com/news/2013501/railways-in-loss-despite-record
 and transparently disclosed.  Third, performance               grants and PKR 34.79 billion in capital investment.                                        Consequently, many SOEs drift from one government   should  prepare  rolling  forecasts,  conduct                                                                                                 -revenues
 should be assessed against a limited set of measurable         According to Dawn, Pakistan Railways’ revenue                                              administration to the  next without  the  commercial   budget-versus-actual  analyses  at  appropriate                                      Phase 5-Review and enforce consequences: Where
 indicators, including operating pro t, cash  ow from           increased from PKR 88.79 billion in FY2023–24 to PKR                                       discipline and managerial consistency required for   responsibility levels, and explain signi cant variances.                               key performance indicators are not met, require
 operations, punctuality, and customer satisfaction. The        92.72 billion in FY2024–25 and PKR 115.16 billion in                                       sustainable performance.                          This would enable management to identify emerging                                         corrective  action,  revise  business  plans  where
 government should then focus on its regulatory role            FY2025–26, despite the enterprise continuing to                                            Government oversight of SOEs is inevitable given their    nancial pressures, take corrective action, and improve                            necessary, and reconsider the management or
 rather than becoming involved in day-to-day                    report losses.                                                                             status as state-owned assets, but political interference   the reliability of  nancial planning.                                            ownership   model    if  performance   remains
 operations.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           unsatisfactory. Continued  nancial support should be
               30   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   30   31   32   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40