Page 38 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 38

F oc us  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                            The reforms aim to:                              2.    Strengthen Board Governance
                  From Public Liability to Economic Asset:                                                                                                  •  Strengthen  nancial discipline and corporate      •  Appoint  quali ed  and  independent  board
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    members.
                                                                                                                                                              governance.
                 Rethinking the Future of SOEs in Pakistan                                                                                                  •  Improve board independence and professional       •   Reduce political interference in operational
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    decisions.
                                                                                                                                                              management.
                                                                                                                                                            •  Establish clearer ownership objectives and        •   Introduce measurable performance targets
                                                                                                                                                              performance expectations.                             and accountability mechanisms.
               Introduction                                     remain major obstacles                                                                      •  Enhance transparency and accountability.          •   Strengthen  nancial reporting and disclosure
                                                                to SOE performance.  A                                                                      • Improve   monitoring   through    centralised         requirements.
               State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) play an important role   recent  assessment                                                                                                                    3.    Undertake Business Restructuring
               in Pakistan’s economy by providing essential services   indicated that:                                                                        institutional oversight.
               in electricity, transport, water and infrastructure.                                                                                         •  De ne and  nance public service  obligations to   •  Address   excessive  costs,  operational
               However, persistent  nancial losses, weak governance   •  86% of SOEs did not                                                                  reduce reliance on open-ended government              ine ciencies and over-employment.
               and dependence on government support have turned    meet key governance                                                                        support.                                           •  Review   debt   and   improve   nancial
               many of these enterprises into a signi cant  scal   requirements.                                                                            These measures provide an important  institutional      management.
               burden.                                                                                                                                      foundation. However, their success will depend on    •   Modernise business processes through digital
                                                                • 64    out   of   74                                                                                                                               transformation.
               The challenge is not simply to privatise or retain state   enterprises failed to                                                             consistent implementation and e ective enforcement.
               ownership. Pakistan needs a more selective approach   comply with at least                                                                                                                        •   Improve asset utilisation and introduce
               that determines which enterprises should remain     60% of the  assessed                                                                     Privatisation and Restructuring: What                   stronger risk management.                                                           International experiences, including reforms in   The SOE Act, 2023 and Ownership and Management
               under public ownership, which require restructuring,                      Mahwish Mehmood                                                    Does the Evidence Suggest?                       4.     Leverage Capital Markets                                                            Ethiopia and other developing economies, also     Policy 2023 have established an important foundation.
                                                                                         Inspector Inland Revenue
               and which may perform better under private          standards.          Federal Board of Revenue (FBR)                                                                                            •   Consider public listings and partial divestment                                    demonstrate the importance of clear ownership     The priority now is to translate these reforms into
               management.                                      •  Political interference,                                                                  International evidence generally indicates that         where appropriate.                                                                  objectives, e ective institutions and transparent   measurable improvements in governance,  nancial
                                                                                                                                                            privatisation can improve operational and  nancial
               The future of SOEs therefore depends on moving from   fragmented  oversight,  weak  board accountability                                     performance,  particularly  where  competition,      •   Use capital markets to mobilise investment                                         privatisation procedures.                         performance and service delivery.
                scal  dependence towards   nancial sustainability,   and limited  nancial transparency continue to                                          regulation  and  institutional  safeguards  are  e ective.   and improve transparency.                                                      Pakistan has made progress in establishing a legislative   Ultimately, the success of SOE reform should not be
               operational e ciency and greater economic value.    a ect performance.                                                                                                                            •   Explore private management arrangements
                                                                                                                                                            However, results vary across countries and sectors.                                                                                         framework, but a gap remains between policy       measured by the number of enterprises privatised or
               Why Does the State Own Enterprises?              The  nancial position also re ects these weaknesses.                                        Research by Bachiller (2017) found that privatisation   where they can improve performance without                                          commitments and implementation. Sustainable       retained, but by their ability to generate economic
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    compromising public objectives.
                                                                During FY2024–25:                                                                                                                                                                                                                       reform will ultimately require domestic ownership,   value, deliver quality public services and reduce their
               State ownership can be justi ed where private markets                                                                                        through public o erings can produce better outcomes   5.     Strengthen Fiscal Risk Management                                              institutional capacity and consistent political support.  dependence on taxpayers.
               cannot adequately serve the public interest or where   •  Pro table SOEs generated pro ts of Rs. 709.9 billion.                              than some alternative methods. Similarly, D’Souza and   •   Identify and  transparently  report contingent
               national priorities require government involvement.   •  Loss-making SOEs incurred losses of Rs. 832.8                                       Megginson (1999) documented improvements in the                                                                                             Conclusion: A Selective and                       References
               Key reasons include:                                                                                                                          nancial and operating performance of privatised        liabilities.                                                                                                                          •   Aftab, S., & Shaikh, S. A. (2025). Reforming the State-Owned Enterprises.
                                                                   billion.                                                                                                                                      •  Introduce  risk-based  provisioning  for                                            Performance-Based Approach                           Cambridge University Press.
               •  Public service delivery: Providing essential                                                                                               rms.                                                   potential government obligations.                                                                                                     •   Bachiller, P. (2017). A meta-analysis of the impact of privatization on  rm
                 services that may not be commercially attractive to   •  The resulting net  nancial position was a loss of                                 For Pakistan, privatisation should therefore be      •   Link  nancial support to measurable                                                Transforming Pakistan’s SOEs from  scal burdens into   performance. Management Decision, 55(1), 178–202.
                 private investors.                                approximately Rs. 122.9 billion.                                                         considered where it can improve e ciency, attract       performance and service delivery.                                                   economic assets requires a di erentiated reform   •   Cabinet  Committee  on  State-Owned  Enterprises.  (2026).  Bi-annual
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        strategy rather than a uniform ownership model.
               • Strategic  interests: Maintaining control over   Some improvement was reported in the  rst half of                                         investment and reduce the  scal burden. However, it   •   Replace open-ended subsidies with clearly                                                                                              Performance Review of Federal SOEs. Government of Pakistan.
                 sectors critical to national security and economic   FY2025–26, when pro table SOEs generated Rs. 423.3                                    should not be treated as a universal solution,          de ned    and   costed  public   service                                            The government should classify enterprises according   •   D’Souza, J., & Megginson,  W. L. (1999).  The  nancial and operating
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             performance of  privatized  rms during the 1990s.  The Journal of
                 stability.                                     billion, while losses of loss-making enterprises                                            particularly for enterprises performing essential public   agreements.                                                                      to their strategic importance, public service role and   Finance, 54(4), 1397–1438.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        commercial viability:
               • Development       objectives:    Supporting    declined to Rs. 342.8 billion. This resulted in a positive                                  or strategic functions.                          Balancing Public Interest and                                                                                                                •   Ministry of Finance. (2023). State-Owned Enterprises (Governance and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Operations) Act 2023. Government of Pakistan.
                 infrastructure and economic activities where private   net  nancial  ow of Rs. 35.6 billion in favour of the                               Strategic Pathways: Turning SOEs into            Commercial Viability                                                                       • Retain: Enterprises essential for national security,   •   Ministry of Finance. (2023). State-Owned Enterprises Ownership and
                 investment is insu cient.                      government.                                                                                 Economic Assets                                                                                                                               strategic interests and critical public services,   Management Policy 2023. Government of Pakistan.
               However, state ownership must have a clear purpose.   Nevertheless, losses remain concentrated in particular                                                                                  SOEs must balance two responsibilities: operating                                            subject to strong governance and performance    •   OECD. (2024). OECD Guidelines on Corporate Governance of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          standards.
               Without de ned objectives and accountability,    sectors.  Ten electricity distribution companies                                            A sustainable SOE reform strategy should move    e ciently as commercial entities and delivering                                                                                                 State-Owned Enterprises. OECD Publishing.
               political interference, administrative ine ciencies and   reportedly incurred losses of Rs. 299 billion and                                  beyond the simple choice between public and private   services in the public interest. These objectives are not                             • Restructure: Enterprises with viable operations but   •   Pilla, L. H. L. de, Peci, A., & Leite, R. de O. (2025). State-owned enterprises,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             public corporate  governance codes, and   nancial performance.
               competing priorities can undermine enterprise    received subsidies of Rs. 551 billion. This highlights the                                  ownership. The following measures can help improve   necessarily incompatible, provided that public service                                   persistent  nancial or managerial weaknesses.      Academy of Management Proceedings.
               performance.                                     need  for  sector-speci c  reforms  alongside  broader                                      performance:                                     obligations are clearly de ned, transparently funded                                       •  Privatise or partially divest: Commercially viable
               The OECD Guidelines on Corporate Governance of   governance improvements.                                                                    1.  Clarify the Rationale for State Ownership    and independently monitored.                                                                 enterprises  where  private  ownership  and
               State-Owned Enterprises (2024) emphasise that state   Pakistan’s Reform Framework                                                               •   De ne why each enterprise needs to remain   The SOE Act, 2023 provides a basis for formalising                                         competition can improve e ciency.
               ownership should serve long-term public value while                                                                                                 under government ownership.               these obligations. Rather than requiring enterprises to                                    •  Reform public service obligations: Ensure that
               ensuring e ciency and sustainability.            The State-Owned Enterprises  (Governance  and                                                  •   Identify its commercial, strategic or public   absorb the cost of non-commercial activities, the                                       essential   non-commercial   activities  are

               Pakistan’s SOE Challenge: Governance             Operations) Act, 2023 and the SOE Ownership and                                                    service objectives.                       government should establish transparent  nancing                                             transparently  funded   and    independently
                                                                Management Policy, 2023 provide the foundation for
               and Financial Performance                        improving the management and oversight of public                                               •   Periodically review whether  continued  state   arrangements that protect both service delivery and                                    monitored.
                                                                                                                                                                   ownership remains justi ed.
                                                                                                                                                                                                              nancial sustainability.
               Weak governance and inadequate accountability    enterprises.
                                                             ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026  33
   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43