Page 31 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 31

A r t ic les  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                            Management  must  oversee  the entire  process,  from
                  The Barriers of Digital Transformation of                                                                                                 planning  through  implementation and evaluation.
                                                                                                                                                            Without de ned milestones and performance
                                                                                                                                                            indicators, projects risk losing direction and may be
                      State-Owned Enterprises in Pakistan                                                                                                   discontinued before delivering their intended bene ts.

                                                                                                                                                            Outdated Infrastructure and Energy Constraints
                                                                                                                                                            Digital transformation depends on reliable IT
               Introduction                                     traceability may also be                                                                    infrastructure and an uninterrupted power supply.
                                                                perceived as challenges                                                                     However, outdated hardware, inadequate storage
               State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) are business entities   to existing work cultures,                                                            capacity, unsupported operating systems and limited
               wholly or partially owned or controlled by national or   making  employees                                                                   network capabilities continue to  constrain the
               local governments.  They perform commercial      reluctant  to   adopt                                                                       technological readiness of several SOEs.
               functions as well as provide essential public services.   t echnology - dr iven
               According to the Annual Aggregate Report on SOEs   processes.                                                                                Frequent power outages and load-shedding further
               (2025), published by the Finance Division, Pakistani                                                                                         disrupt digital operations, reduce productivity and   Limited Integration of Digital Public Services
               SOEs  operate across  eight  core  sectors:   nancial   Limited Availability of                                                              delay automation. Upgrading existing infrastructure
               services; oil and gas; power; infrastructure and   Funds                                                                                     and ensuring reliable energy supplies are therefore   Although numerous digital platforms operate in                                        Key priorities include developing digital platforms,   and  transparency  of  Pakistan's  SOEs.  However,  its
               transport,  including  ICT;  manufacturing;  mining  and   As government-owned                                                               essential  prerequisites  for  large-scale  digital  Pakistan, many public services remain fragmented                                       standardising operating procedures and integrating   success depends on addressing persistent barriers,
               engineering; industrial estate development; and   entities,  many  SOEs                                                                      transformation.                                  across separate applications and systems. Citizens                                         electronic documentation and e-procurement systems   including resistance to change, funding delays, limited
               trading, marketing and miscellaneous activities.  must  follow  formal   Faraz Memon, FCMA                                                   Inadequate Post-Implementation Maintenance and   often have to access multiple platforms to complete                                        into institutional processes.                     digital skills, leadership discontinuity, outdated
               The report also highlights the  limited  adoption  of   approval procedures to   Director, Risk Management & Costing                         Support                                          di erent transactions, while disconnected databases                                        •  Integrated Enterprise Architecture             infrastructure  and  inadequate   maintenance
                                                                                          Patel Hospital, Karachi
                                                                                                                                                                                                             restrict the smooth exchange of information between
               digital technologies across several SOEs. Continued   secure  funding  for                                                                   Digital transformation does not end with the     institutions.                                                                              The policy promotes an integrated enterprise      arrangements. Fragmented digital platforms and weak
               reliance on manual systems contributes to delays in   digital  transformation  initiatives.  Lengthy                                         installation of software or the launch of a digital                                                                                         architecture through the alignment of national    data governance further restrict progress.
               decision-making, reporting errors and inadequate risk   administrative processes and delays in fund allocation                               platform.  Systems  require regular  maintenance,   This fragmentation creates inconvenience for users                                      databases, digital platforms and institutional software   The Digital Pakistan  Policy provides a  framework for
               monitoring. These weaknesses undermine operational   can hinder project execution and implementation.                                        security updates, technical support and continuous   and limits the e ectiveness of digital public services.                                systems.  This approach is intended to facilitate   addressing these challenges through integrated
               e ciency, productivity and transparency across the   Furthermore, funds are not always released according                                    improvements to remain e ective.                 Greater integration is required to provide seamless                                        seamless data sharing, strengthen knowledge       enterprise  systems,  workforce  development,
               SOE sector.                                      to predetermined schedules. This creates di culties                                         However, many implemented projects face di culties   access to government services through interoperable                                    management and improve coordination across public   e-governance  and   stronger   accountability
               The Pakistan Digital Authority (PDA) projects that   for technology partners and vendors in meeting                                          in  securing  adequate post-deployment support.   platforms.                                                                                sector organisations.                             mechanisms.  Nevertheless,  policy objectives must
               digital transformation could generate economic value   project timelines, maintaining resources and ensuring                                 Procurement and contracting procedures may not   Digital  Transformation Objectives for                                                     •  Digital Skills and Change Management           translate into sustained institutional action. Given the
               of up to USD 80 billion by 2030. However, achieving   continuity of service.                                                                 su ciently distinguish software development and   SOEs under the Digital Pakistan Policy                                                                                                      strategic importance of SOEs to Pakistan's economy, a
               this potential will depend on timely implementation,   Lack of Digital Literacy                                                              maintenance from conventional service contracts,                                                                                            Recognising the importance of human capital, the   coordinated  and  adequately  funded   digital
               e ective  coordination   among    government                                                                                                 creating challenges in retaining specialised technical   The Government of Pakistan introduced the Digital                                  policy  emphasises the  development  of digital  skills   transformation strategy is essential to modernise their
               departments  and  the  integration of  existing  digital   Limited digital skills among employees remain a                                   expertise.                                       Pakistan Policy to expand access to a ordable, reliable                                    and e ective change management.                   operations, strengthen public service delivery and
               platforms.                                       signi cant obstacle to technology adoption. Many SOE                                                                                         and accessible ICT services. It promotes the adoption                                      It encourages the placement of quali ed IT        realise  the  potential  economic  gains  from
                                                                employees lack the competencies required to operate                                         Software  maintenance  also  requires  specialised  skills   of emerging technologies to support socio-economic                                                                               digitalisation.
               Digital Transformation Challenges                modern digital systems, while insu cient training and                                       and an understanding of the systems' underlying   development, strengthen public service delivery and                                       professionals across SOEs, alongside structured   References
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        training and capacity-building programmes.
               Faced by SOEs in Pakistan                        professional development further widen the skills gap.                                      architecture. Without dedicated support arrangements   transform economic activities.                                                       These initiatives aim to equip employees with the skills
                                                                                                                                                            and clearly de ned service standards, technical issues
               Digital transformation o ers signi cant bene ts,   The challenge  also  extends  to  senior management,                                      can remain unresolved and undermine the long-term   The policy's vision is:                                                                 required to operate digital systems, adapt to     •  https://www.pda.gov.pk/
               including  paperless operations,  faster processing,   where limited understanding of digital technologies                                   value of digital investments.                                                                                                               technological developments and support a more     •  https://moib.gov.pk/Downloads/Policy/DIGITAL_PAKISTAN
               improved information management and reduced      can a ect project  evaluation, planning and                                                 Absence of a Comprehensive Data Governance                                                                                                  innovative organisational culture.                   _POLICY%2822-05-2018%29.pdf
               manual intervention. However, several institutional,   decision-making.  Without sustained investment in                                     Framework                                                                                                                                   •  Transparency and Accountability                •  https://www.phoneworld.com.pk/pakistan-80-billion-
                nancial and technical barriers continue to impede its   capacity building, employees may continue relying on                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 digital-transformation-economic-gains-2030/
               adoption across Pakistan's SOEs.                 traditional practices, while outdated IT systems remain                                     E ective digital transformation requires reliable data                                                                                      The policy emphasises the use of digital tools to
                                                                unaddressed.
               Resistance to Change and Organisational Culture                                                                                              management and coordination across departments.                                                                                             establish transparent, traceable and accountable   •  https://mittalsouthasiainstitute.harvard.edu/2020/09/8-
                                                                Frequent Changes in Leadership                                                              However, limited data sharing and inconsistent                                                                                              institutional processes. Key measures include digital   challenges-pakistans-digital-transformation-journey/
               Digital transformation involves more than introducing                                                                                        information management within SOEs can result in                                                                                            audit trails, performance dashboards and online
               new software or automating existing processes; it   Frequent changes in senior management can disrupt                                        duplication, miscommunication and delays in                                                                                                 reporting systems.
               requires fundamental changes in organisational   the continuity of digital transformation projects. In                                       administrative processes.                                                                                                                   These mechanisms can strengthen monitoring, clarify
               practices and working methods. Many public sector   Pakistan, institutional initiatives are sometimes                                        The absence of clearly de ned data governance    The policy identi es several priorities relevant to the                                    responsibility for assigned tasks and improve public
               employees remain accustomed to paper-based       delayed, revised or abandoned following changes in                                          arrangements also creates uncertainty regarding data   digital transformation of SOEs.                                                      access to institutional performance information,
               documentation, manual data entry and extensive   leadership, resulting in the loss of resources and                                          storage, backup, access, sharing and anonymisation. A                                                                                       thereby reinforcing trust in government institutions.
               administrative procedures.                       progress.                                                                                   comprehensive framework is essential to ensure data   •  E-Governance Enablement
               Consequently, the introduction of digital systems can   Successful  implementation  requires  consistent                                     security,  consistency and interoperability across   The policy encourages SOEs to adopt ICT solutions to                                   Conclusion
               disrupt established practices and create resistance to   leadership commitment, clear project ownership and                                  government institutions.                         improve public service delivery, operational e ciency                                      Digital  transformation  presents  a  signi cant
               change. Greater transparency, accountability and   regular performance monitoring.                                                                                                            and transparency.                                                                          opportunity to improve the e ciency, productivity

               26   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36