Page 27 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 27

F oc us  S ec t ion



               Transfer of Managed Establishments (1978)                                                                                                   These models illustrate that PPPs can serve not merely   development and management to provincial and local                                 Privatisation versus Public-Private               Based on the  nancial position and strategic
                                                                                                                                                           as  nancing instruments but also as mechanisms for   governments.  This would enable projects to re ect                                                                                       signi cance of individual enterprises, the following
               In 1978, the Transfer of Managed Establishment Order                                                                                        institutional transformation, innovation and improved   regional  requirements  and  community-level                                        Partnerships: Understanding the                   di erentiated approach is recommended in table 3.
               (TMEO) introduced a mechanism through which                                                                                                 governance.                                       development priorities while strengthening local                                          Di erence
               shares and associated property rights could be o ered                                                                                                                                         institutional capacity,  nancial de-risking and                                                                                             Linking Financial Performance with
               to original owners. However, the mechanism remained                                                                                         Beyond infrastructure, PPPs can contribute to the   technical assistance.                                                                   Although both privatisation and PPPs involve      Reform Priorities
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       private-sector participation, they di er fundamentally
               underutilised and did not result in widespread                                                                                              development of education, healthcare, digital                                                                                               in terms of ownership, operational control, duration   The Federal State-Owned Enterprises Annual
               private-sector ownership.                                                                                                                   platforms, a ordable housing and other essential   Given Pakistan's limited  scal resources and                                                                                               Aggregate Report for FY2024–25 provides an
 The Growing Case for SOE Reform in   Five-Year  Privatisation  Privatisation and Denationalisation (1990–1993)                                            public services. Their e ectiveness, however, depends   substantial development requirements, PPPs can help                                 and allocation of risk.                           important evidence base for identifying the  nancial
                                                                                                                                                           on the government's ability to design transparent
                                                                                                                                                                                                             bridge the gap between infrastructure needs and
 Pakistan  Programme (2024–2029).  A renewed privatisation drive began in 1991 with the                                                                    contracts, establish accountability mechanisms and   available public  nancing, provided they are                                           The choice between these approaches should depend   and  governance  challenges  requiring  policy
 Under the government's                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                on the commercial viability, strategic importance and   intervention.
 Pakistan's federal government owns more than 207    scal triage exercise, 84   denationalisation of Muslim Commercial Bank (MCB),                         maintain public con dence.                        supported  by   sound   planning,  transparent                                            public-service obligations of each enterprise rather   The Table 4 links the major weaknesses identi ed in
 entities classi ed as State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs),   major commercial SOEs   targeting key sectors and drawing inspiration from the                    Strengthening the Institutional Framework for PPPs  implementation and e ective institutional oversight.                                    than following a uniform ownership model.         the report with corresponding reform measures.
 operating  across  eight  major  sectors:  Financial;   were assessed. Of these,   privatisation policies  pursued under Margaret   Pakistan  faces  an  estimated  infrastructure   nancing                Changing Regulatory and Tax
 Infrastructure,  Transport and  ITC; Manufacturing,   44  entities (52%) were   Thatcher in the United Kingdom.  gap of USD 124 billion by 2040, while public debt   The growing role of  PPPs  requires a corresponding
 Mining and Engineering; Oil and Gas; Power; Industrial   designated for complete   Between 1990 and 1993, approximately 115 industrial   stands at 66.3% of GDP. These pressures highlight the   transformation in the government's institutional   Environment for PPPs
 Estate Development;  Trading and Marketing; and   privatisation  or  units, including banks and manufacturing enterprises,   limitations of relying exclusively on conventional   responsibilities. Rather than acting solely as a  nancier   PPPs  in  Pakistan  have  traditionally  been  used  to
 Miscellaneous.                                                 public  nancing and create a need for alternative                                          or project implementer, the government must       mobilise private investment and deliver public
 liquidation, while 39   were privatised.  The process, however, attracted   investment arrangements.                                                      increasingly function as an enabler by establishing
 The  nancial performance of these sectors varies   entities  (46%)  were  criticism over allegations of political favouritism,                            clear regulations, monitoring performance and     infrastructure and services. However, recent legal,
 considerably. While a limited number of enterprises   identi ed for strategic   procedural irregularities and inadequate transparency.   PPPs as Instruments of Financing and Operational   ensuring transparency throughout the project cycle.  regulatory  and  taxation  developments  have
 contribute signi cantly to the overall pro tability of   restructuring  and  These concerns also  raised  questions  about wealth   E ciency                                                                introduced additional considerations for project
 the SOE portfolio, others continue to accumulate   retention.  concentration,  employment  and  the  broader  Although PPPs are frequently viewed as an alternative   This requires:                        structuring and  nancial viability.
 substantial losses. These  nancial di culties re ect a   The  142-item  Economic  Governance  Reform  Agenda   socioeconomic implications of privatisation.   nancing mechanism, their potential extends beyond   •   Strengthening institutional capacity for PPP   The Finance Act, 2026 and draft amendments released
 combination of factors, including circular debt, global   announced in January 2026 also identi es SOE reform   mobilising private  capital.  They  can also  facilitate   project design, evaluation and management.  by the Securities and Exchange Commission of
 economic developments, climate-related challenges,   as a central pillar, targeting  nancial losses, operational   Limited Privatisation and Economic Outcomes   technological innovation, operational e ciency,   •  Simplifying  procurement  procedures  and  Pakistan  (SECP)  in  June 2026 represent  important
 weak governance and erosion of equity.  ine ciencies and collective liabilities exceeding PKR 9   (1993–1996)  improved service delivery and better value for money.  administrative processes.             developments with potential  implications for PPP
 According to the Ministry of Finance's Annual   trillion. The ongoing privatisation programme further   Between 1993 and 1996, privatisation activity slowed   Through the Public-Private Partnership Authority   implementation.
 Aggregate Report on SOEs for FY2024–25, pro table   seeks to reduce the state's commercial footprint   considerably. Approximately 20% of the 112 industrial   (P3A), established in 2018, the government has   •   Improving transparency and accountability   The key areas of concern are outlined below in table 1.
 SOEs collectively generated pro ts of PKR 709 billion,   through targeted ownership and management   units, one  nancial institution, one power plant and   provided an institutional framework for attracting   throughout project implementation.  These developments highlight the importance of   A Di erentiated Approach to SOE                   Conclusion: Towards a Balanced SOE
 while loss-making entities recorded aggregate losses   reforms.  12% of PTCL shares were privatised.  private-sector  investment  and  expertise  into     •  Developing   e ective   risk-sharing  and     regulatory predictability and tax certainty in attracting
 of PKR 832.8 billion.  The broader policy debate centres on whether shifting   Despite these transactions, the expected improvement   infrastructure development and public services.  dispute-resolution mechanisms.  long-term private investment. Clear transitional                               Reform                                            Ownership and Reform Strategy                                                              Under this approach, privatisation is appropriate
 The  reported  Fiscal  E ciency  Index  of  1.01  further   from public to private management can improve   in  scal conditions remained uncertain, partly because   Experts emphasise that PPPs should move beyond   •   Strengthening provincial and local government   provisions and consistent application of tax rules are   Pakistan's SOE reform strategy should account for   SOE reform in Pakistan needs to move beyond the             where commercial activities can be  performed
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    e ciently by  competitive  private  markets.  PPPs
 highlights the limited  scal returns generated by the   operational  e ciency,  service  quality,  cost  rising  interest  payments  o set  some  of  the  gains   serving as substitutes for public expenditure and   capacity to identify and manage PPP projects.  particularly important for maintaining investor   changing  global  economic conditions, domestic   conventional debate over public versus private                           more suitable for  strategic  assets  and public-ser
 SOE portfolio relative to government support.  This   management  and revenue  generation  through   generated through privatisation proceeds.  instead become instruments for e ective risk   An important priority is decentralising PPP   con dence in infrastructure concessions.                 political  considerations  and  the  long-term    ownership. The more fundamental question is which                                          responsibilities that require continued government
 indicates that for every PKR 1 of government support,   commercially driven strategies.  During this period, GDP growth declined from 5.44% in   allocation, corporate e ciency and innovation.                                                                                                       sustainability of public services. Reform decisions must   combination  of ownership,  nancing,  management                                  participation but can bene t from private capital,
 SOEs return approximately PKR 1.01, re ecting their   Pakistan's Experience with   the pre-privatisation period (1986–1991) to 4.15% in   Financing mechanisms such as in ation-linked bonds,                                                                                                         be transparent, commercially sound and aligned with   and governance arrangements can generate the                                           technology and management expertise. Restructuring
 continued  dependence  on  public  resources  and   Privatisation: Historical Perspective  the post-privatisation period (1992–1997). Investment   blended  nance and revenue-sharing  arrangements                                                                                                   public interests rather than in uenced by political   greatest  economic  and public value from  each                                        is necessary where otherwise viable enterprises su e
 limited capacity to generate sustainable internal cash   levels also declined from 5.55% to 1.82%.  can further strengthen their viability.                                                                                                                                                           preferences.                                      enterprise.                                                                                primarily from governance or operational de ciencies
  ows.  Pakistan's privatisation journey has evolved through   These historical developments demonstrate that   The  ve-year National Economic Transformation Plan                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Meanwhile, continued state ownership is justi ed
 Legislative and Institutional Reforms  several phases, re ecting changing economic   privatisation receipts alone do not necessarily translate   (2024–2029), URAAN Pakistan, also emphasises                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      where    national   security,  natural-monopoly
 priorities, political considerations and approaches to
 The State-Owned Enterprises  (Governance  and   public-sector management.  into sustained economic growth or  scal stability. The   institutional reforms and improved governance to                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               characteristics or essential public-service  obligat
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    require direct government involvement.
                                                                        a
                                                                           more
                                                                                  sustainable
                                                                                              environment
                                                                create
                                                                                                           for
 Operations) Act, 2023, represents  a  signi cant   Industrial Development and the Early Privatisation   outcomes depend on the transparency of transactions,   private-sector collaboration.
 legislative development and an initial step towards   Phase (1952–1972)  the regulatory environment, market conditions and                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         This di erentiated approach positions privatisation,
 implementing a broader governance and  scal reform   the e ective utilisation of proceeds.  International Experiences and Best Practices                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           PPPs, restructuring, regulated state ownership and
 agenda. A subsequent policy amendment in October   Pakistan's industrial development initially relied   Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs): An   International experiences demonstrate how PPP                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     orderly liquidation as complementary instruments
 2026 introduced a uni ed International Financial   heavily  on  public-sector  investment.  The  arrangements can help bridge infrastructure and                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   within a broader SOE reform strategy rather than
 Reporting Standards (IFRS) reference framework for   establishment of the Pakistan Industrial Development   Alternative Approach to SOE Reform  public-service gaps.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               isolated policy interventions.
 commercial SOEs registered under the Companies Act.  Corporation (PIDC) facilitated the development of   Given the  nancial and political implications of   Examples include the Private Finance Initiative in the                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Ultimately, the objective should not simply be to
 Other major reform measures include greater   approximately 90 industrial projects, including Karachi   complete privatisation, Public-Private Partnerships   United Kingdom, the National Concessions System in                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   reduce the number of state-owned enterprises or
 private-sector  representation  on  SOE  boards,  the   Shipyard and Engineering  Works Limited, Pakistan   (PPPs) have increasingly attracted attention as an   Chile, the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI)                                                                                                                                                                                                                            transfer ownership to the private sector. It should
 establishment of oversight bodies, replacement of the   Machine Tool Factory, Heavy Mechanical Complex, Sui   alternative  mechanism  for  addressing  infrastructure   and major airport concessions in India, as well as                                                                                                                                                                                                                         establish a  nancially sustainable, operationally
 legacy 2004 procurement framework with the 2026   Northern Gas Pipelines Limited and Sui Southern Gas   constraints,  scal limitations and public-service   subnational small-scale PPPs and state-level water                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     e cient and accountable SOE portfolio that delivers
 Public Procurement Rules, and implementation of the   Company Limited.  delivery challenges.  concessions in Brazil.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               long-term economic and public value.


               22   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32