Page 24 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 24

F oc us  S ec t ion



 •  Philippines — The GOCC Governance Act, 2011,   enterprises since 2016 has reached 8¾ percent of GDP.
 and the Governance Commission for GOCCs (GCG)   To address these challenges, Pakistan has enacted the   Table 1: Di erentiated Reform Pathways for
 provide centralised supervision of performance   SOE Act (2023), followed by the Ownership and   Pakistan's State-Owned Enterprises
 evaluation, appointments and remuneration to the   Management Policy (2023), and set up the Central
 board, restructuring, mergers and privatisation. The   Monitoring Unit (CMU).  The IMF is withholding the
 lesson for Pakistan is that the evaluation of   next $1 billion tranche until Pakistan amends 9–10 SOE   SOE category   Key characteristics   Recommended approach and   Example
 performance should be coupled with accountability    Performance Measures
 of boards and remedial measures.   laws  to  align  with  the  SOE  Act,  2023  at mid of   Commercially   Pro table,   nancially  Retain under professional state  Pakistan  Railways  —Revenue Recorded

 November, 2026, as deadline Pakistan has repeatedly
 •  Brazil — Law No. 13,303/2016 strengthens internal   missed deadline of August 2026 while SOE debt has   viable SOEs   sustainable   and  ownership,   with   more  Rs 115.157 billion in FY2025-26, a 24.19%
 control, standards and compliance in public   ballooned to Rs 10.1 trillion. The government should   operating   in  autonomy  in  the  board,  and  increase  over  the  previous  year  and
 procurement processes.  There is a  lesson for   also put in place an e ective implementation of the   competitive markets   clearly  de ned  commercial  the  highest  in  its  history.  The
 Pakistan in this; it is to increase transparency and   objectives             turnaround was driven by governance
 strengthen internal controls while reducing   new  legal  regime,  the  completion  of  the  plans  for   Performance   Measures:   reforms,  digitalization,  public-private
 corruption risks and not compromising on   privatisation and restructuring of the SOEs, and the   partnerships, and cost management.
 commercial e ciency.   reinforcement of the role of the CMU in overseeing the   Pro tability,  return  on  assets,
                                                    productivity.
 • Indonesia  —  The implementation of the   performance of SOEs.  The following actions are
 necessary to improve e ciency, reduce the e ects of
 strengthening of  the  BUMN  Law  and  the BUMN   Strategically   O er  key  services  or  Adopt   a   time-bound   Pakistan International Airline--PIA
 institution in 2025 has resulted in the centralisation   the public  nances and to better serve citizens.  important   but  support   strategic  restructuring  plan,  enhance   accumulated Rs 500bn in losses over
 of BUMN institutions' supervision, which refers to   A Tailored Framework for SOE Reform  underperforming  sectors   and   have  management   accountability,   the past decade, with its decline
 state ownership and holding companies. The lesson   SOEs   ongoing  weaknesses  and   regularly   review   the   beginning in 2009. In December
 for Pakistan is: State and holding companies' roles in   The governance and ownership of public enterprises   in their operations or  progress of restructuring.   2025, the airline was privatised when
 ownership and coordination vis-à-vis individual   should not be uniform, in accordance with SOE reform.    nances.   the Arif Habib Consortium acquired a
 Preamble   plan that is rolled out every three years. The Act also   SOEs need to be clearly communicated.   The state ownership of  uniform  state-owned   Performance   measures:   75% stake for Rs 135 billion. The new
 recognizes that enterprises are involved in activities   enterprises (SOE) should be replaced by a speci c   Achieve reduction in operating
 State-owned enterprises (SOEs) play an important role   not only out of business interest, but also for public   •  South Africa — The draft National State Enterprises   portfolio strategy that considers strategic importance,   losses,  e ciency  and  reliability   owners plan to more than triple the
 in Pakistan's economy by delivering critical services,   policy.   Bill introduces a 'holding company' structure to   viability, and  nancial risk. In this model, the   of service provision    eet to 64 aircraft.
 supporting strategic industries, and implementing   improve the e ectiveness of coordination and   performance targets are strict for the viable units or
 public  policy.  But  their  performance  and  International Experiences in SOE   oversight  of  state  enterprises.  The  lesson for   private transition, and the non-viable enterprises are   SOEs  suitable  for  Operate  in  markets  Privatisation,   competitive  Three Major International Airports
 accountability have been called into question due to   Governance  Pakistan is to think about mechanisms for central   merged and/or privatised or closed.  This ends   private   where  private  sector  concession,  joint  venture  or  +  6  DISCOs  +  5  Other  Entities.  The
                                investment,
                                                    public-private
                participation
 longstanding governance issues, political interference,   oversight, but remember this is a proposal, and not   continuous  nancial bailouts through independent   partnership  revised 5-year privatization roadmap
 operational ine ciencies, and  nancial risk.  The   The international experience shows that there is no   a law.   evaluations to maximize economic e ciency and  scal   competition   or  (PPP),  depending  on  feasibility  covers 25 SOEs across 3 phases, with
                                alternate
 State-Owned  Enterprises  (Governance  and  one-size- ts-all formula for SOE reform, ranging from   •  China  – The State-owned Assets Supervision and   sustainability.  Table 1 shows di erentiated reforms   mechanisms   delivery  and  safeguards  for  the  public  11 entities in Phase 1 (within one year).
                                               can  interest.
 Operations) Act, 2023 is an important initiative to   an explicit commercial mandate in New Zealand,  a   Administration Commission (SASAC) is responsible   pathways for Pakistan's SOE portfolio.  deliver   greater
 overcome the challenges in order to establish a more   centralised Governance Commission in the Philippines   for the centralised management of state-owned   Gap, Challenges & Recommendations  e ciencies.   Performance   Measures:
 structured governance framework for the state-owned   to a governance law focused on integrity in Brazil, to   assets and enterprises. The lesson for Pakistan is to   Investment,  service  quality,
 enterprises  to  re-establish  the  ownership,  holding company models in Indonesia and South   specify the ownership and the coordinated   The Act is broadly drafted, although it may be inhibited   operating  e ciency  and   scal
 monitoring
 of
 systematic
 oversight
 and
 management, monitoring, and disclosure principles.   Africa, centralised asset oversight with accountability   performance as in SASAC.   by a number of weaknesses.  These challenges point to   savings.   References  • https://pro t.pakistantoday.com.pk/2026/07/25/pakistan-railways-
 The Act is based on international practices that   in China, and existing company law with explicit   a mismatch  between  the  governance  principles   SOEs with explicit  Provide   socially  Introduce   Public   Service  Power   Distribution   Companies   •  Law No. 19 of 2003 on State-Owned Enterprises, as amended by Law No.   posts-record-rs115bn-revenue-in-fy26-up-24percent
 attempt to reconcile commercial discipline with   ownership policies in Europe; but in all these variant   •  European  countries —  Through clear  and open   identi ed by the Act and the institutional capacity   public-service   required services that  Obligation  Agreements  with  (DISCOs)  —  IESCO,  LESCO,  MEPCO,   16 of 2025 (Indonesia).  • https://tribune.com.pk/story/2583882/pia-buyers-o ered-hefty-tax-
                                                                                                                                                                                                               exemptions#1
 public-sector responsibilities. However, the success of   approaches, the clear message for Pakistan is that the   accountability and ownership goals, existing   needed to ensure e ective governance.  Table 2   mandates   may   not   be  costed   and   clear   service  etc.  manage  government  subsidies   •  Law  of  the People's  Republic of  China  on State-Owned  Assets in   • https://english.aaj.tv/news/330451679/pia-privatisation-completed-
 SOE reform is not just dependent on quality legislation   key to successful SOE governance is the clear de nition   company law and state ownership policies, such as   highlights key governance gaps and challenges in   economically   self-  standards and compensation.   and  relief  packages,  creating  non-  Enterprises, 2008.  as-govt-arif-habib-consortium-sign-transaction
 those in Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Germany and
 but also on the independence of the institutions and   of ownership objectives, centralised and accountable   the United Kingdom, have created a framework that   Pakistan’s SOE  sector and  outlines corresponding   supporting   when   Performance Measure: Cost per  commercial costs. Under the SOE Act   •  Lei nº 13.303 de 30 de junho de 2016 (Lei das Estatais) (Brazil).  • https://www.atifmian.com/p/how-good-is-pias-privatization?utm_
 the ability of oversight bodies to punish enterprises   oversight, measurable performance indicators tied to   supports European countries.  The takeaway   recommendations to address them.  o ered individually.   bene ciary,  service  coverage,  2023, PSO Agreements aim to ensure   •  National State Enterprises Bill [B1-2024] (South Africa), Parliament of the   medium=android&r=2eczvt
                                                                                                                                                             Republic of South Africa.
 and government o cials.  board responsibility, increased transparency and   message for Pakistan is that 'good governance' of   quality,   and   compensation  these  costs  are  fully  funded  by  the   •  OECD, Guidelines on Corporate Governance of State-Owned Enterprises,   • https://www.arabnews.pk/pakistan/pakistan-minister-boeing-chief-
                                                                                                                                                                                                               discuss-acquisition-of-16-aircraft-for-pia-2651241#1
 internal controls, and unambiguous coordination   SOEs  is  possible  through  the  existing  legal   Conclusion  government.  In  FY2025,  recovery        revised edition, 2024.
 Pakistan’s State-Owned Enterprises   between the state, holding entities, and individual   framework, provided that there are well-de ned   The SOE Governance and Operations Act, 2023 has   transparency.   reached  96.6%,  under-recoveries  fell   •  OECD, Ownership and Governance of State-Owned Enterprises 2024,   • https://dailyausaf.com/en/business/govt-unveils-major-privatization-
                                                                                                                                                                                                               plan-islamabad-karachi-and-lahore-airports-included/#1
                                                                                                                                                             OECD Publishing, Paris.
 Act, 2023  enterprises.   goals of ownership, professional management and   huge potential in the area of governance and   42%,  and  T&D  losses  declined  to   •  Pakistan Sovereign Wealth Fund Act, 2023.  • https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/25-Aug-2026/pakistan-steel-mills-gets-
                                                                                                                                                                                                               rs58-billion-from-govt-despite-decade-long-shutdown#1
 Pakistan's State-Owned Enterprises Act, 2023 is a   •  New Zealand — Under the State-Owned   accountability.  operations of state-owned enterprises of Pakistan. But   17.6%.   •  Republic Act No. 10149, the GOCC Governance Act of 2011 (Philippines).  • https://pro t.pakistantoday.com.pk/2025/12/19/psm-considers-
 lengthy piece of legislation comprising 37 sections, 11   Enterprises  Act,  1986,  New  Zealand established  a   SOE Reform as a Fiscal-Risk   the law is not enough to guarantee sustainable reform.   SOEs  without  a  No   clear  Considerations   of   merger,  Pakistan  Steel  Mills  (PSM)  —  Shut   •  State-Owned Enterprises (Governance and Operations) Act, 2023, Gazette   renting-4200-steel-town-units-to-earn-rs1-44bn-annually#respond
                                                                                                                                                             of Pakistan,  Extraordinary, 2 February  2023, as updated  by Ordinance
 chapters and 6 schedules. It proposes a framework to   commercial operating framework requiring SOEs to   Management Instrument  This will require its consistent application, professional   sustainable   demonstrated   orderly closure or exit, including  down  since  June  2015,  yet  received   dated 5 June 2024.  • https://www.brecorder.com/news/40327113
                                                                                                                                                                                                             • https://tribune.com.pk/story/2633564/imf-tranche-tied-to-soe-reforms
 improve the performance of SOEs with respect to the   operate as successful businesses, with a focus on   and independent boards, credible performance   ownership   continuing   public  legal   obligations,   market  approximately Rs 58 billion from the   •  State-Owned Enterprises (Ownership  and  Management) Policy,  2023,
                                                                                                                                                             Finance Division, Government of Pakistan.
 setting and strengthening of commercial targets,   pro tability,  e ciency  and  performance  SOE reform is an important tool for managing  scal   monitoring, and a government that is ready to address   rationale   ownership  rationale,  conditions and social costs.   government  over  the  past  decade   •  State-Owned Enterprises Act 1986 (New Zealand), No. 124 of 1986.
 strengthening the boards of directors and the   comparable to private-sector enterprises. The key   risks and  reducing the   nancial burden on  the   long-term  nancial risks and ine ciencies.  The   and  have  ongoing   Performance  Measures:  Fiscal   despite  zero  production.  Cumulative   •  World Bank, Corporate Governance of State-Owned Enterprises: A Toolkit,
 transparency of their reporting, and the systematic   lesson for Pakistan is to establish clear commercial   government. Moreover, the governance of SOEs must   measurable outcomes approach will help to ensure   viability issues.   savings,  liabilities  resolved  and   losses  now  stand  at  roughly  Rs  600   Washington, DC, 2014.
 way of government oversight. An important factor is   objectives, measurable performance targets  and   also be assessed within the context of Pakistan's   that SOE performance is enhanced, public  nances are   continuity of essential services.   billion, with annual interest payments   •  Note:  Table 2: Authors’ proposed framework, informed by the OECD
 that the SOEs are required to pursue certain   accountability  mechanisms  to  assess  SOE   scal-risk management system. The total amount of   not strained, and essential services are delivered based   of nearly Rs 20 billion.   Guidelines on Corporate Governance of State-Owned Enterprises (2024)
                                                                                                                                                             and the State-Owned Enterprises (Governance and Operations) Act, 2023.
 commercial goals and prepare a three-year business   performance.  direct government budget support  to these   on statutory requirements.                • https://pid.gov.pk/site/press_detail/32046#1
                                                             ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026  19
   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29