Page 42 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 42

F oc us  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                           Leadership and Institutional Revival              The Implementation Challenge
                                   The Three Pillars of Enterprise Performance
                                                                                                                                                           The Role of Leadership Commitment                 The framework also provides for transparent treatment
                                                                                                                                                           The revival of loss-making SOEs requires commitment   of public-service obligations. Where the government
                                                                                                                                                           from  the  highest  level  of  leadership.  Clear  direction,   requires an SOE to provide a service at a price below its
                       Efficiency                      Productivity                 Competitiveness                                                          timely decisions and consistent accountability can   cost, the resulting  nancial di erence should be
                                                                                                                                                           address many of the weaknesses that have persisted   addressed through an explicit subsidy.
                                                                                                                                                           for years.                                        However, the e ectiveness of these arrangements
 Introduction: The Growing Cost of SOE   enterprises  are                                                                                                  Strong leadership must actively discourage political   depends on implementation. Board autonomy must
 Underperformance  inherently ine cient or                                                                                                                 interference, nepotism and con icts of interest. It   be meaningful, appointments should be merit-based,
 that privatisation is the
                                                                                                                                                                                                             and performance monitoring must lead to timely
 Pakistan’s State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) play a   only  solution.  Efficiency means using available   Productivity involves   Competitiveness requires     should also empower professional management to    corrective  action.  Without  these  safeguards,
                                                         generating greater
                                                                                       an enterprise to deliver
                         resources optimally while
 critical  role  in  the  national  economy,  particularly  in   International examples   controlling costs and avoiding   output from existing   reliable products and   make timely commercial decisions while holding it   administrative  structures  alone  cannot  deliver  the
 strategic sectors such as power,  oil and gas,   demonstrate that state   waste. It requires operational   resources through better   services at prices and   accountable for measurable outcomes.         desired transformation.
 infrastructure,  transport  and   nance.  However,  their   ownership can coexist   discipline, effective   deployment of   quality levels that enable     International Governance Models
 persistent  nancial losses, operational weaknesses and   with strong  commercial   management and responsible   employees, machinery,   it to remain sustainable                                            Lessons from Three Steel Mills
 poor service delivery  have  placed  a  considerable   performance.  use of capital.  technology and   in the market.                                     The performance of international enterprises
                                                            innovation.
 burden on public  nances and the wider economy.  China operates  a vast                                                                                   demonstrates the importance of institutional      The contrasting experiences of Pakistan, India and                                        By  contrast,  the prolonged development  of the
                                                                                                                                                                                                             South Korea o er an important illustration of how
                                                                                                                                                           commitment.  Singapore's  Temasek  model, for
 During FY2024–25, loss-making federal SOEs incurred   portfolio  of wholly and                                                                            example, separates  the  government's role in     leadership and institutional commitment in uence the                                      Diamer-Bhasha Dam, accompanied by substantial
 aggregate losses of Rs 832.8 billion. Total accumulated   partially  state-owned  The government may retain legal ownership, but   Creating Economic Value While   policymaking from the commercial management of its   performance of public-sector enterprises.                                     increases in estimated costs, highlights the
 losses  to  date have reached Rs  6,848.9  billion, while   enterprises, while Saudi   boards, chief executives and relevant public o cials               investments.  This provides a distinct ownership                                                                                            consequences of delays and weak project execution.
 total sovereign guarantees issued stand at Rs 2,164.0   Aramco,  Emirates  must demonstrate genuine accountability for the   Protecting Public Welfare    structure focused on long-term value creation.    All three countries established major steel facilities
 billion and total government support provided   Airlines and Singapore’s   organisations under their control.  Converting Resources into Economic Value                                                     with foreign technical assistance, yet their subsequent                                   These examples demonstrate that institutional
 reached Rs 2,078.5 billion. These  gures highlight the   Temasek have demonstrated the commercial potential   Economic value is created when a product or service   China's SOE model also demonstrates the importance   trajectories di ered signi cantly.                                           discipline and timely decision-making are essential for
 urgency of addressing the structural weaknesses that   of state-linked businesses. At the domestic level,   Article 29 of the Constitution of Pakistan provides the   becomes useful, accessible and a ordable at a   attached to state oversight and institutional discipline,   POSCO, South Korea  delivering large-scale public investments.
 continue to undermine their performance, as the   organisations such as OGDC, PPL, KPT and NBP have   framework for the application of the Principles of   particular place and time. Natural resources, for   although its governance arrangements di er                                             Privatisation: A Solution or an
 sector currently destroys approximately Rs 2,020   also demonstrated that public ownership does not   Policy by organs and authorities of the State.  This   considerably from those of other economies.    Established in 1968 with an initial capacity of
 billion in economic value (EVA) annually.  automatically result in  nancial losses.  The Fauji   broader responsibility reinforces the importance of   example, have limited economic value until they are   approximately 1.3 million tonnes, POSCO expanded                                         Admission of Management Failure?
 Foundation, which operates through a group of                  extracted, processed and made available for                                                The World Bank and Asian Development Bank have    substantially over the following decades. Its growth
 The problem is not necessarily public ownership itself.   companies, provides another example of substantial   public o cials acting in accordance with their   productive use. Similarly, seawater becomes useful for   emphasised governance improvements, institutional   was supported by consistent leadership, investment in   Assessing the Right Course of Action
 Rather, it raises fundamental questions about   commercial activity under institutional ownership.  institutional obligations.  human consumption only after treatment.  capacity, performance evaluation, transparency, board   automation, reinvestment of pro ts and a strong focus                Privatisation is often presented as the principal remedy   Public assets should not be allowed to deteriorate
 leadership, accountability, decision-making and the            SOEs have an important role in converting national                                         accountability and appropriate commercial incentives                                                                                        for loss-making SOEs. While it may be appropriate for   through neglect and then be disposed of at distressed
 sense of responsibility with which these enterprises are   These examples reinforce an important point: the   The persistent decline of enterprises such as Pakistan   resources into economic value. However, the cost of   as important elements of SOE reform. These principles   on productivity and international competitiveness.  certain enterprises, it should not automatically be   valuations. Timely decisions are essential, whether the
 managed. Two recurring weaknesses stand out such as   performance of an enterprise depends less on who   Steel Mills, several power distribution companies and   this process must be managed carefully. Enterprises   o er useful guidance for Pakistan.  Bhilai Steel Plant, India                  considered the only option.                       chosen  course  is  restructuring,  partnership  or
 nepotism and delayed decision-making. Both weaken   owns it on paper and more on how it is governed,   Pakistan Railways raises a fundamental question: who   operating in oil, gas, power, water and transport must   Established in 1958 with an initial capacity of                                                                                  privatisation.
 institutional discipline, discourage merit and prevent   managed and held accountable.  takes responsibility for their performance? When the   seek e ciency through research and development,   Pakistan's SOE Governance Framework  approximately 1 million tonnes, the plant experienced           The decision to privatise should follow a thorough
 timely corrective action.  Ownership: Beyond Legal Control  government owns the enterprise but no individual or   automation, better procurement, reduced overheads   The SOE (Governance and Operations) Act, 2023  several operational and  nancial challenges but                                  assessment of an enterprise's  nancial position,   Conclusion: A Choice Between
 Public Ownership Does Not Mean Poor   Developing a Sense of Institutional Responsibility  institution takes ownership of its results, accountability   and improved operational practices.  Pakistan introduced the SOE (Governance and   continued to evolve and remains an important part of        strategic importance, market conditions and prospects   Ownership and Apathy
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       for recovery. Before transferring public assets to private
               becomes diluted.
 Performance                                                    Balancing Commercial Performance and Public                                                Operations) Act, 2023, to strengthen the governance   India's steel industry.                                                               ownership, the government should examine whether   Pakistan’s SOE crisis is not a consequence of public
 The concept of ownership extends beyond legal or   Pakistan Steel Mills is a particularly striking example of   Welfare                                   and management of state-owned enterprises.  The   Pakistan Steel Mills                                                                      restructuring, professional management, operational   ownership  but  re ects  weaknesses  in  leadership,
 The Economic Importance of SOEs  physical possession. It also involves a sense of   how institutional neglect, delayed decisions and a lack   Unlike ordinary commercial products, essential utilities   framework seeks to clarify the government's role as                                          improvements or public-private partnerships could   governance and management. Their revival requires
 Many SOEs operate in sectors that directly a ect   responsibility and commitment  among  those   of responsibility can undermine a strategic national   have a direct bearing on public welfare.  Their   policymaker and owner, strengthen board autonomy   Established with an initial production capacity of   deliver better results.               committed leadership that ensures integrity, timely
                                                                                                                                                                                                             approximately 1.1 million tonnes, the facility ceased
 economic stability and public welfare.  The federal   entrusted with managing an organisation.  When   asset.  performance cannot be assessed exclusively through   and improve performance monitoring.                                                                                                                                                 decision-making  and  freedom   from   undue
 portfolio  includes  enterprises  in  power,  oil  and  gas,   employees, managers and leadership consider an   SOEs operating in monopolistic or protected   pro tability. While  nancial sustainability is necessary,   Key institutional arrangements include:  operations in 2015.  Years of neglect, governance   Making Management Accountable for Turnaround  interference, alongside professional management
                                                                                                                                                                                                             weaknesses and delayed decisions have left a major
 infrastructure and  nancial services, among other   enterprise their responsibility, they are more likely to   environments may face limited competitive pressure   a ordability, availability and service quality must also                                                                          The chief executives of loss-making enterprises should   focused on productivity, e ciency, innovation and
 areas.  Their performance in uences the cost,   protect its assets, improve performance and pursue its   to improve their operations.  Without appropriate   remain central objectives.  •  Cabinet Committee on SOEs: Oversees broad   industrial asset largely unutilised.                          also be held accountable for presenting credible   responsible use of public resources. Ultimately,
 availability and quality of essential services.  long-term interests.  performance targets and accountability, this can   Where the government requires an SOE to provide   ownership policies and related decisions.  The contrast is not simply about ownership. It re ects                         turnaround plans with measurable targets and realistic   sustainable  improvement  depends  on  developing  a
 When these enterprises operate ine ciently, the   In a private company,  nancial gains and  losses   weaken cost discipline, service quality and  nancial   services below commercial cost for public-policy   •  Central Monitoring Unit (CMU): Located in the   di erences in institutional continuity, investment   timelines.  Their performance should be assessed   genuine  sense  of ownership, where  those entrusted
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         with public assets take responsibility for performance
 consequences  extend  beyond  their   nancial  primarily a ect its investors. In an SOE, however, the   sustainability.  reasons, the resulting obligation should be   Ministry of Finance, it is responsible for monitoring   decisions, management accountability and the ability                   against improvements in productivity, reduction in
 statements. Expensive utilities, supply disruptions,   consequences ultimately extend to the State and its   transparently identi ed and appropriately funded. This   SOE performance and reporting.        to respond to changing industrial requirements.                                           losses, service quality and  nancial sustainability.  and remain accountable for results.
 inadequate infrastructure and declining service quality   citizens. Public losses are borne by taxpayers, while   The solution lies in strengthening management   would help distinguish genuine public-service costs   Infrastructure Development: The Cost of Delayed                               Privatisation should not become a substitute for
 increase the cost of doing business, constrain   ine ciencies  are re ected  in  the  cost  and  quality  of   practices,  introducing  modern  technologies,  from operational ine ciencies.  •  Line  ministries: Maintain their respective policy   Decisions                                      institutional accountability. Equally, public ownership
 industrial activity, a ect agricultural productivity and   services.  encouraging innovation and linking managerial   The objective should be to establish a sustainable   and oversight responsibilities.                                                                                            should  not be retained merely  to avoid di cult
 place additional pressure on households.  performance with measurable results.  These three   balance between commercial performance and public           • Independent  boards: Intended to strengthen     Pakistan's  experience with major  infrastructure
 Accountability as a Public Responsibility                                                                                                                                                                   projects o ers another perspective.  Tarbela and                                          decisions.  The objective must be to protect public
 International and Domestic Examples  pillars should be embedded in the organisation's   welfare, ensuring that essential services remain                    professional  management    and    corporate    Mangla dams were completed in 1976 and 1967,                                              value and select the most appropriate ownership and
 The real challenge is to develop a culture of ownership   operating culture rather than treated merely as   accessible without placing an excessive burden on   accountability.                                                                                                                       management structure for each enterprise.
 It would be incorrect to conclude that public-sector   among those responsible for public enterprises.   performance indicators.  public  nances.                                                           respectively, and remain important national assets.


                                                             ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026  37
   37   38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47