Page 46 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 46

F oc us  S ec t ion



               While conventional  nancial statements explain what   E ective capital management does not mean simply                                      Performance Measurement and                       Digitalization and ERP-Based                                                              A Practical Performance Framework for
               has happened, management accounting helps explain   reducing investment. It means directing available                                       Accountability                                    Management Information                                                                    Pakistan
               why it happened and what corrective action is    resources towards projects and assets that o er
               required.                                        sustainable economic and operational returns.                                              SOE performance assessment should move beyond     Digital systems can strengthen SOE e ciency by                                            A  practical  improvement  model  can  be  organized
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 integrated
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        timely,
                                                                                                                                                                                                             providing
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 accurate
               For example, an increase in operating expenditure   Working-Capital and Cash-Flow                                                           the traditional focus on annual pro ts and losses. A   management information.                                                              around six connected steps. It begins with assessing
                                                                                                                                                           balanced framework should consider  nancial results
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       the current position and ends with regular reviews that
               should not simply be recorded as a higher cost.   Management                                                                                alongside operational e ciency, capital utilization,                                                                                        inform future planning.
               Management should identify the activities responsible,                                                                                      service delivery and governance.                  An  Enterprise  Resource  Planning (ERP)  system  can
                                                                                                                                                                                                             connect procurement,  inventory, operations,  billing,
 Pakistan’s State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) play a vital   Understanding   determine  which  departments  incurred  the  Weak working-capital management can undermine an                                     receivables,  payables,  general  ledgers  and   nancial                                  1.  Diagnose: Assess  nancial, operational,
 role in the national economy, particularly in strategic   Productivity and   expenditure and assess whether the additional   enterprise even when it reports an accounting pro t.   Pakistan’s existing SOE monitoring framework already   reporting. Such integration reduces duplicate data            governance and service-delivery performance to
 sectors such as energy, transport, utilities and   spending generated corresponding improvements in   Delayed customer payments, excessive inventory and   covers  nancial and operational performance,  scal   entry,  improves  reconciliation  and  provides                                          identify weaknesses and improvement
 infrastructure. Their performance has implications not   E ciency  output or service delivery.  ine cient payment processes can create cash                ows, debt, governance, business plans and key    management with a more complete view of                                                      opportunities.                                 Conclusion
 only for public  nances but also for economic stability,   Productivity  measures  Tools such as activity-based costing, variance analysis,   shortages, increase borrowing requirements and raise   performance indicators. The challenge is to ensure that   organizational performance.            2. Segment: Classify activities according to      Improving   the  productivity,  e ciency  and
 service delivery and national competitiveness.  the output generated   responsibility accounting, budgeting and rolling    nancing costs.                 these indicators are used as active management tools   Management and boards should have access to digital                                     commercial performance, strategic importance and   competitiveness of Pakistan’s State-Owned Enterprises
                                                                                                                                                           rather than merely reporting requirements.
 Improving their performance requires more than   from the resources used   forecasts can provide this level of insight.  SOEs should regularly monitor:                                                     dashboards covering key indicators, including:                                               public-service obligations.                    requires  a shift from  a reporting-focused approach
 reducing losses or controlling expenditure. It calls for a   by an organization. For   Segment-level pro tability analysis is equally   •  Days Sales Outstanding (DSO): Time taken to collect   KPIs should be linked to clear responsibilities, realistic   •  Receivables and overdue balances     3. Measure: Establish standardized  nancial and   towards active performance management.
 coordinated approach that strengthens  nancial   SOEs, these resources   important. Consolidated   nancial  statements  may   receivables.                targets and regular management reviews.  Where    •  Inventory levels and working-capital requirements                                         operational KPIs with clear targets.           The  nancial position of many SOEs highlights the
 discipline, operational productivity, asset utilization,   include  capital,  conceal substantial di erences in the performance of                        performance falls below  expectations, management                                                                                           4. Improve: Implement targeted measures covering   urgency of reform. However, sustainable improvement
 working-capital management, governance and digital   employees, infrastructure,   individual products, services, geographical areas and   •  Days Inventory Outstanding (DIO): Time inventory   should identify the underlying reasons, assign   •  Budgeted versus actual expenditure                   costs, working capital, asset utilization,     will not come from expenditure cuts alone. It requires
 information systems.                                             remains in stock.                                                                        corrective actions and monitor their implementation.
 equipment, energy and   business units. Reviewing these segments separately                                                                               This  establishes  a  continuous  performance-    •  Capital project costs and progress                                                        procurement and digital systems.               better management of capital, working capital and
 This article presents a practical six-step framework   working capital. Outputs   enables management to identify pro table operations,   •  Days Payable Outstanding (DPO):  Time taken to   management cycle:  •  Procurement performance                                                            5. Account: Assign clear responsibility for       assets, supported by transparent governance, reliable
 such as Diagnose, Segment, Measure, Improve,   may  range  from  activities requiring restructuring and services that may   settle supplier payments.                                                       •  Cash- ow forecasts                                                                        performance targets to boards, senior          digital information and  measurable performance
 Account, and Review to help SOEs translate  nancial   commercial revenue to electricity generation,   be  nancially unviable but essential to public-service   •  Cash  Conversion  Cycle:  Time  required  to  convert                                                                                  management and relevant departments.           targets.
 and operational information into better decisions and   transportation, infrastructure and  other  public   obligations.  operating expenditure into cash receipts.                                         •  Asset utilization                                                                                                                        Pro tability  and  cash  generation  remain  important,
 sustainable economic and public value.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                6. Review: Conduct regular performance reviews and
 services.     This distinction supports more informed decisions on   Receivables should be monitored by age, customer                                                                                       •  Financial and operational KPIs                                                            update business plans in light of actual results.  but they should be assessed alongside operational
 Introduction  Higher revenue does not necessarily indicate   resource allocation, cost control, investment priorities   and outstanding dispute. Delays in collection should                                The Ministry of Finance has also emphasized the                                           This framework shifts management attention from   productivity, capacity utilization, service quality and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         the achievement of strategic objectives.
 State-Owned Enterprises have historically contributed   improved productivity. If operating costs rise faster   and performance targets.  be investigated to identify weaknesses in billing,   Governance and Financial Discipline  digitalization of SOE information and IFRS-aligned                preparing  nancial statements to actively managing
 to Pakistan’s economic development by providing   than revenue, e ciency may deteriorate. Similarly, an   Capital Allocation and Asset Utilization  contract terms and recovery procedures.  Productivity improvement cannot be achieved    nancial reporting to strengthen transparency and           nancial and operational performance.             Management accountants can make a meaningful
 essential services, managing strategic infrastructure,   enterprise may own substantial assets but generate   According to the FY2025 o cial report, federal SOEs   Inventory management also requires greater attention.   without e ective governance. Weak oversight, unclear   evidence-based decision-making.                                      contribution by connecting  nancial and operational
 supporting employment and operating in sectors   inadequate returns from them.  collectively held assets  worth  approximately  PKR  38   Identifying slow-moving, obsolete and excess stock   responsibilities and inadequate  nancial controls can   However, digitalization should not be treated merely   The Role of Management Accountants        information, identifying ine cient resource use and
 where  continuity of  service  is critical. However,   trillion. Ensuring that this substantial asset base is used   can release cash and reduce storage costs. Better   undermine  even  well-designed  operational  as an IT initiative. Its real value lies in converting                          Management accountants can play a central role in   supporting better  allocation  of capital.  Their role
 persistent  nancial and operational weaknesses have   A balanced performance framework should therefore   productively should be a management priority.  demand forecasting and procurement planning can   improvement programmes.  reliable information into timely management action.               improving SOE productivity by connecting  nancial   should extend beyond reporting results to helping
 made their performance a signi cant economic   combine  nancial and operational indicators.  further improve inventory control, while just-in-time                                                                                                                                                    information  with  operational  decisions.  Their  management improve them.
 concern.  Financial indicators may include:  Key indicators such as asset turnover, return on assets,   practices may be appropriate where demand and     E ective governance requires clearly de ned board   International Lessons                                                                   contribution extends beyond  nancial reporting to   Ultimately, Pakistan needs SOEs that use public
               capacity utilization and maintenance costs can help                                                                                         responsibilities, competent oversight, transparent                                                                                          budgeting, costing, forecasting, capital-investment   resources responsibly, operate e ciently, maintain
 The FY2025 federal SOE report highlights the scale of   •  Return  on  Assets  (ROA)  and  Return  on  Invested   identify underutilized or idle assets. Such assets carry   supplier reliability permit.   International experience shows that no single reform                                      analysis, working-capital management, variance
 the challenge. Pro t-making SOEs recorded aggregate   Capital (ROIC)  an opportunity cost because capital remains tied up   Regular cash- ow forecasting is equally important. It    nancial reporting, timely audits, sound risk   approach is suitable for every SOE. Possible                      analysis and performance measurement.              nancial discipline and deliver measurable economic
 pro ts  of approximately  PKR 709.9  billion, while   •  Cash- ow generation and asset turnover  without generating adequate  nancial, operational or   enables  management  to  anticipate  liquidity  management and accountability for business-plan   interventions include stronger corporate governance,                                          and public value. Making performance information an
 loss-making SOEs incurred aggregate losses of around   public value.  requirements, plan payments and reduce dependence                                   performance.                                      operational restructuring, increased competition,                                         These functions help management understand where   integral part of management decisions, rather than a
 PKR 832.8 billion. After adjustments, the portfolio   •  Working-capital ratios and debt sustainability  on emergency borrowing or government support.    The World Bank has highlighted SOE governance and   public-private partnerships and, where appropriate,                                     resources are  being  consumed,  what  outputs  they   compliance exercise, is an essential step towards
 recorded a net loss of approximately PKR 122.9 billion.   Operational indicators may include:  Capital projects also require stronger oversight.           scal exposure as important areas of reform in    changes in ownership.                                                                     generate and whether those outputs justify the    achieving this objective.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       resources invested.
 The report also placed total SOE assets at   •  Operating cost per unit of output  Management  should  regularly  Table 1: Monitoring Framework for Performance Assessment  Pakistan. Government support in the form of subsidies,   The  choice  depends  on each enterprise’s economic                                                                Reference
 approximately PKR 38 trillion, against liabilities of PKR   compare approved budgets with                                                                 grants,  loans  and  guarantees can  create   scal  risks   role,  nancial position and market environment.                                 For SOEs, where decisions often involve substantial
 31.7 trillion.  •  Capacity utilization and employee productivity  actual  expenditure,  planned  Performance area   Illustrative indicators              when      enterprises   remain     persistently                                                                                             public resources, management accountants can help   •  Why reforms for state-owned enterprises (STATE OWN ENTERPRISESs)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           remain critically important for growth, jobs, and development. Available
 •  Service reliability and quality  completion dates with project                                                                                                                                           For   Pakistan,  this  means    adopting   an                                             answer three fundamental questions:                 at:https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/governance/why-reforms-for-state
 These  gures raise an important question: are the   progress, and expected bene ts                                                                        underperforming.                                  enterprise-speci c approach. SOEs operating in                                                                                                -owned-enterprises--soes--remain-critically?utm_source
  nancial, human, technological and physical resources   Together, these measures help management identify   with outcomes achieved after   Financial  Operating margin, ROIC, cash generation  An important distinction must therefore be made   competitive commercial markets may require cost      •  What resources are being consumed?             •  Pakistan  |  World  Bank  Group.  Available  at:  https://www.worldbank.org
 controlled by these enterprises generating su cient   where resources are being consumed, how e ectively   implementation.                                between commercial ine ciency and the cost of     restructuring, improved productivity and stronger                                         •  What outputs are being generated?                /ext/en/country/pakistan?utm_source
 economic and public value?  they are being used and whether they are generating   Operational  Capacity utilization, cost per unit, productivity          ful lling public-service obligations. Where an SOE is    nancial discipline. Those providing essential public                               •  Are these resources creating su cient  nancial and
 measurable results.  Post-investment  reviews  can                                                                                                                                                          services may need a broader performance framework                                           economic value?
 Productivity and e ciency must therefore become   identify weaknesses in project   Capital    Asset turnover, project cost variance                       required to provide a service that is not commercially
 central measures of SOE performance. Financial results   Strategic Financial Management  planning,  procurement,  cost                                    viable, the associated cost should be identi ed and   that considers service quality, reliability and                                       By providing timely and relevant management
 alone cannot provide a complete assessment of   estimation and execution.  These   Service    Reliability, customer complaints, response time             reported transparently. This allows management and   public-service obligations alongside  nancial results.                                 information,  nance professionals can support boards
 whether these organizations are using their resources   Financial management can improve SOE productivity    ndings can then inform future                oversight  bodies  to  assess  commercial  performance   The objective should be to identify the right                                      and executives in making informed decisions,
 e ectively or delivering the services expected of them.  when  nancial information is directly linked to   investment decisions.  Governance    Audit completion, reporting and compliance    without overlooking legitimate public responsibilities.  intervention for each enterprise  rather than apply a   identifying  ine ciencies  and  strengthening
 operational decisions.                                                                                                                                                                                      uniform reform model.                                                                     accountability.

                                                             ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026  41
   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51