Page 49 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 49

A r t ic les  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                            What matters is how public enterprises are governed,   market  discipline  and  attract  investment.
                    Transforming State-Owned Enterprises:                                                                                                   monitored and held accountable. strengthening  the  Public-private partnerships and strategic private
                                                                                                                                                                                                             investment can also provide capital, technology and
                                                                                                                                                                         focused
                                                                                                                                                                   has
                                                                                                                                                                                  on
                                                                                                                                                            China
             From Fiscal Dependence to Economic Contribution                                                                                                competitiveness of its central SOEs, with greater   management  expertise  without   necessarily
                                                                                                                                                                                                             transferring full ownership.
                                                                                                                                                            emphasis on innovation, strategic investment and
                                                                                                                                                            measurable performance.
                                                                                                                                                                                                             Build a Performance-Driven Culture
                                                                                                                                                            Vietnam has pursued restructuring and partial    Each enterprise should operate under a standardised
               The Cost of Underperformance                     A uniform approach to                                                                       divestment,  placing  greater  importance  on    performance framework supported by measurable key
                                                                                                                                                                                                             performance  indicators,  digital  monitoring systems
                                                                                                                                                            transparency, enterprise valuation and modern
               State-owned enterprises (SOEs) control substantial   all SOEs is unlikely to                                                                 corporate governance.                            and management performance contracts. Financial
               public assets and play a critical role in Pakistan’s   succeed. Each enterprise                                                              Uzbekistan has sought to reduce the government's   targets should be accompanied by service delivery,
               economy, particularly in electricity, transport,   needs a reform strategy                                                                   role in competitive sectors, strengthen independent   productivity and asset utilisation indicators.
               infrastructure and essential services.  Yet, instead of   based on its commercial                                                            oversight and attract institutional investors through its
               consistently generating economic value, many have   viability, public purpose                                                                                                                 From Ownership to Accountability
               become a recurring burden on public  nances.     and         long-term                                                                       National Investment Fund.                        The real test of SOE reform is not how many enterprises
               In FY2024–25, loss-making SOEs recorded combined   contribution  to  the                                                                     Although these approaches di er, they o er a     remain under public ownership or are transferred to
                                                                economy.
               losses of Rs. 832.8 billion, while government support                                                                                        common lesson that a successful SOE reform requires   the private sector. It is whether these enterprises use
               reached Rs. 2.078 trillion, an increase of 37%.  The   The Governance                                                                        clear ownership objectives, professional management,   public resources e ciently, provide reliable services
               sector’s outstanding debt stood at approximately Rs.   and Performance                                                                       transparent decision-making and performance-based   and contribute to national economic development.
               9.57  trillion,  including  around  Rs.  2.03  trillion  in               Muhammad Junaid                                                    accountability.                                  Pakistan has taken important steps through the SOE
               unfunded pension liabilities.                    Gap                            Moeen                                                        Turning Public Assets into Economic              Act 2023 and its ownership and management policy.
               These  gures point to a fundamental problem: public   Weak governance remains   Ph.D Scholar                                                 Value                                            The next priority is to translate these frameworks into
               capital is tied up in enterprises that often fail to deliver   one of the major reasons                                                                                                       practical improvements in enterprise performance.
               adequate  nancial or operational returns. The resulting   behind the underperformance of Pakistan’s SOEs.                                    Pakistan needs to move from a system of repeated   The government must move beyond repeatedly
                scal pressure limits the resources available for   Political interference, unclear mandates, inadequate                                      nancial support towards one in  which public     nancing losses and adopt the role of an active,
               essential priorities such as education, healthcare and   board oversight and limited transparency have                                       investment is assessed against measurable results. Five   performance-oriented  owner.  Public  service
               infrastructure.                                  weakened operational discipline and accountability.                                         priorities can help achieve this transition.     obligations  should  be  transparently  funded,
               The challenge, therefore, is not simply to reduce   The Asian Development Bank’s assessment of                                               Link Financial Support to Performance            commercial   operations  should  be   nancially
               government ownership, but to ensure that public   Pakistan’s SOE sector has highlighted weaknesses in                                        Government assistance should not be automatic.   disciplined, and underperforming  enterprises  should
               assets deliver measurable economic and social value.  governance, monitoring arrangements and  nancial                                       Financial support  should  be  linked  to  agreed   face meaningful restructuring.
                                                                disclosure. The problem is further aggravated when
               Rethinking the Purpose of State                  enterprises are required to provide services at                                             performance   targets,  including  pro tability,  Ultimately, public assets must work for the public. The
                                                                                                                                                            operational e ciency, service delivery and return on
               Ownership                                        below-cost rates without adequate government                                                invested capital. Enterprises that consistently fail to   transition from  scal burden to economic value will
               State  ownership  remains  justi ed  where  enterprises   compensation.                                                                      meet their targets should be required to implement   depend  on  ensuring  that  every  rupee  invested  in
                                                                                                                                                                                                             state-owned enterprises delivers a measurable
               serve  strategic  national  interests,  provide  essential   A sustainable reform programme should focus on:                                 corrective business plans.                       return—whether through  nancial performance,
               public services or support areas where private   1.  Appointing professional and independent boards.                                         Strengthen Corporate Governance                  essential  services,  stronger  infrastructure  or
               investment  is  insu cient.  However,  ownership  must   2.  Strengthening  nancial reporting and timely audits.                             Professional and independent boards should have   sustainable economic growth.
               have a  clearly  de ned  purpose and measurable   3.  Introducing measurable performance indicators for                                      clear responsibilities for strategic direction, risk
               outcomes.                                           management.                                                                              management and management oversight. Regular     References
               The OECD Guidelines on Corporate Governance of   4. Linking  government    nancial  support  to                                              performance reviews, transparent  nancial statements   •  Finance Division, Government of Pakistan. (2025). Federal SOEs Annual
               State-Owned Enterprises (2024) emphasise that       operational improvements.                                                                and stronger audit enforcement are essential to    Aggregate Report FY2025.
               governments should act as informed and active                                                                                                improving accountability.                        •  Asian Development Bank. (2026). Strengthening State-Owned Enterprises
                                                                                                                                                                                                               through Improved Governance and Business Restructuring.
               owners, ensuring that enterprises operate e ciently   5.  Clearly de ning and compensating public service                                    Rationalise the SOE Portfolio                    •  Ministry of Finance, Government of Pakistan. (2023). State-Owned
               while ful lling their public policy objectives.     obligations.                                                                             Not every enterprise needs to remain under         Enterprises (Governance and Operations) Act 2023.
               For Pakistan, this requires distinguishing between   The State-Owned Enterprises  (Governance  and                                           government ownership. Strategic and essential service   •  OECD. (2024). OECD Guidelines on Corporate Governance of State-Owned
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Enterprises.
               three broad categories:                          Operations) Act, 2023 provides an important                                                 providers may be retained with appropriate       •  World Bank. (2025). Pakistan Development Update: SOE Reform for
                                                                foundation for these changes. However, legislation
               Strategic enterprises: Those essential for national   alone cannot transform the sector. Its e ectiveness                                    safeguards,  while  commercially  viable  but  ine cient   Growth.
               security, critical infrastructure and public service   depends  on  consistent  implementation  and                                          enterprises should be restructured.  Where private
               delivery.                                        accountability.                                                                             ownership can improve performance and competition,
               Commercial enterprises: Those operating in                                                                                                   privatisation or partial  divestment  should  be
               competitive markets and expected to generate     Lessons from International Experience                                                       considered.
               sustainable  nancial returns.                    Experiences from other countries demonstrate that                                           Mobilise Private and Capital Market Investment
               Underperforming enterprises: Those requiring     state ownership and economic e ciency are not                                               Listing commercially viable SOEs on the stock
               restructuring, private investment, management    necessarily incompatible.                                                                   exchange can improve transparency, strengthen
               changes or possible privatisation.

               44   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54