Page 53 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 53

A r t ic les  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                            Privatised entities should not continue to depend on   professional boards, greater managerial autonomy and                                 Policy Priorities                                 References
                       Beyond Bailouts: Charting a New                                                                                                      preferential  treatment,  implicit  subsidies  or  market   clearer accountability.                                                         The following measures can help translate the reform   •   Finance Division, Government of Pakistan. (2025). Federal
                                                                                                                                                            protection.  Where an enterprise is fundamentally
                                                                                                                                                                                                             An important institutional development is the
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             State-Owned Enterprises Annual Aggregate Report, FY2025.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        agenda into measurable results:
                                                                                                                                                            unviable, liquidation may also need to be considered
                              Course for Pakistan’s SOEs                                                                                                    rather than repeatedly committing public resources to   establishment of the Central Monitoring Unit (CMU)                                  •  Strengthen SOE governance: Ensure quali ed     •   Faraz,  N.,  &  Samad,  G.  (2022).  Public  Sector  Enterprises  (PSEs)  in
                                                                                                                                                                                                             within the Finance Division. Its role includes
                                                                                                                                                            an unsuccessful sale process.
                                                                                                                                                                                                             monitoring SOE  nancial performance, assessing                                               independent boards, clear mandates and greater     Post-Privatization: Evidence from Pakistan. Journal of Applied
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1239–1259.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Economics,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                25(1),
                                                                                                                                                            The power  sector  presents another  major test.  The   operational risks and evaluating  nancial and                                         operational autonomy under the SOE Act 2023.       https://doi.org/10.1080/15140326.2022.2104553
               Introduction                                     Although        these                                                                       privatisation process for IESCO, FESCO and GEPCO has   quasi- scal implications.  The integrated digital                                    •  Link funding to performance: Make government   •   Megginson, W. L., & Netter, J. M. (2001). From State to Market: A
                                                                developments indicate                                                                       been initiated, while further distribution companies   reporting platform further supports standardised data                                                                                     Survey of Empirical Studies on Privatization. Journal of Economic
               Pakistan’s  state-owned  enterprises  (SOEs)  are  at a   progress, they do  not                                                             are expected to follow. However, the government must   collection and  performance  monitoring  (Finance                                       nancial support conditional on measurable
               critical stage. Despite this footprint, many continue to   eliminate the underlying                                                           rst address circular debt arrangements and      Division, 2025).                                                                              nancial and operational targets, including ROIC   Literature, 39(2), 321–389. https://doi.org/10.1257/jel.39.2.321
               place  pressure on  public   nances, with  accumulated   structural weaknesses.                                                              outstanding  nancial obligations to ensure that these   However, implementation remains critical. SOE boards                                  and EVA.                                        •   State Bank of Pakistan. (2024). Annual Report 2023–2024: Chapter 7
               losses reaching Rs. 7.22 trillion. The portfolio’s thin net                                                                                  liabilities do not continue to undermine the  nancial   must  comprise  quali ed  and  independent                                          •  Adopt a di erentiated ownership strategy:         – Reforming State-Owned Enterprises in Pakistan.
               pro t of Rs. 80.5 billion masks an unrecognized balance   Sustainable improvement                                                            position of the companies after privatisation (Pro t by   professionals with the authority to make commercial                                 Identify entities suitable for privatisation, PPPs,   •   Daily Times. (2026, January 3). Lessons from PIA's privatisation go
               sheet risk of up to Rs. 2.5–3.5 trillion from unfunded   will  require  better                                                               Pakistan Today, 2026).                           decisions  without  unnecessary   administrative                                             concessions or continued state ownership.          far beyond the sale price.
               pensions and IFRS gaps as per H1-FY2026 report.   nancial management,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      •   Pro t by Pakistan Today. (2026, August 31). CCoP seeks alternative
                                                                commercial   discipline                                                                     Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs)               interference. Political and bureaucratic involvement in                                    •  Address legacy liabilities: Resolve outstanding
               The issue extends beyond  nancial losses. Continued   and  accountability                                                                    Not  every  SOE  requires  a  complete  transfer  of   routine management can weaken accountability and                                       debt, pension obligations and sector-speci c       to circular debt  nancing ahead of DISCO privatisation.
               government support absorbs scarce  scal resources,   rather than continued                                                                                                                    discourage capable professionals from serving on                                              nancial weaknesses before privatisation.       •   Pro t by Pakistan  Today. (2026, September 15). SOEs report
               while ine cient operations and limited competition   reliance on government   Muhammad Musab Mirza                                           ownership.  Public-private partnerships  o er an   boards.                                                                                                                                       Rs342.8bn loss in H1 FY26.
                                                                                                                                                            alternative where the government wishes to retain
               constrain private-sector participation. Pakistan’s SOE   support.             PhD Scholar in                                                                                                  Equally important  is  the  transparent  treatment  of                                     •  Formalise public service obligations: Cost,    •   The Nation. (2025, July 14). Finance ministry proposes
               reform agenda, therefore, needs to move beyond   Privatisation:              Corporate Finance                                               ownership while engaging private-sector expertise,   Public Service Obligations (PSOs). Some SOEs provide                                     contract and transparently  nance all              performance-linked funding model for state-owned enterprises.
               reducing losses towards improving governance,    Moving Beyond a Change of                                                                   investment and operational capacity.             services that may not be commercially viable but                                             non-commercial services provided by SOEs.       •   The News on Sunday. (2026, January 4). Privatisation vs
               operational e ciency and economic value creation.  Ownership                                                                                 This approach is particularly relevant to infrastructure,   remain essential for public welfare. Such obligations                           •  Improve market competition: Strengthen            public-private partnership.
               The State-Owned Enterprises  (Governance  and                                                                                                transport, energy and public-service delivery.   should be clearly de ned, costed and funded through                                          regulatory oversight and ensure that privatised   •   World Bank. (2023). Reducing the Fiscal Impact of State-Owned
               Operations) Act, 2023 the SOE Ownership and      Privatisation  remains an important component of                                            Pakistan's airport management initiatives illustrate this   explicit  government  allocations  rather  than  being                            enterprises operate under fair and competitive     Enterprises: Pakistan Public Expenditure Review 2023.
               Management Policy, 2023 and the government's     Pakistan's  SOE  reform  strategy. The  government  has                                     distinction: rather than selling Karachi, Lahore and   concealed within operating losses. This would allow                                    conditions.                                     •  https://www. nance.gov.pk/publications/FY_2026_SOE_
               privatisation programme provide a framework for this   identi ed up to 50 entities for privatisation over the                                Islamabad airports, the government has considered   enterprises to distinguish commercial performance                                                                                            Biannual_Report%20_6%20Months.pdf
               transition.  The central question is how privatisation   next three to four years, with the process covering                                 long-term concession arrangements to improve     from the cost of delivering public services.                                               •  Expand digital monitoring: Use the CMU's
               and public-private partnerships (PPPs), supported by   energy  distribution  companies,  aviation  and  other                                operational e ciency and service standards.      Turning Reform into Economic Value                                                           reporting platform to improve transparency, track
               stronger governance, can help transform SOEs from   commercial enterprises.                                                                  Similarly, PPPs  can  support  investment  in  energy                                                                                         performance and identify  nancial risks.
                scal liabilities into productive economic entities.  However, Pakistan's experience demonstrates that                                       infrastructure, including battery energy storage   Pakistan's SOE reform agenda requires a di erentiated                                    Conclusion
               Understanding the Scale of the                   transferring  ownership  alone  does  not  guarantee                                        systems, without requiring the government to  nance   approach  rather  than a uniform ownership model.                                     Pakistan's SOE  challenge is no longer simply about
                                                                                                                                                                                                             Commercially viable entities operating in competitive
               Challenge                                        improved performance. Research on post-privatisation                                        the entire investment.                           markets may be suitable for full privatisation.
                                                                enterprises has found mixed results, with some  rms                                                                                                                                                                                     reducing  nancial losses; it is about ensuring that
               The FY2025 SOE report presents a mixed picture of the   recording insigni cant or negative performance                                       The  distinction between privatisation  and  PPPs is   Enterprises requiring substantial investment or                                      public assets generate sustainable economic and
               sector. The portfolio's return on invested capital (ROIC)   changes (Faraz & Samad, 2022). Similarly, lengthy                                important. Privatisation transfers ownership, whereas   specialised  management  may  bene t  from                                          social returns. The reforms introduced through the SOE
               stood at approximately 2.2%, substantially below its   transaction processes and institutional weaknesses                                    PPPs establish  contractual  arrangements through   concessions and PPPs, while strategically important                                     Act 2023, the privatisation programme and the
               estimated weighted average cost of capital (WACC) of   have  a ected  the  pace  and  e ectiveness  of  earlier                              which private partners may  nance, develop, operate   entities may remain under state ownership with                                        growing use of PPPs provide an opportunity to address
               around 15%. The resulting negative EVA indicates that   initiatives.                                                                         or manage public assets. The choice should depend on   stronger governance and performance requirements.                                    long-standing weaknesses.
               the  portfolio  is  not  generating  su cient  returns  to   The privatisation of Pakistan International Airlines (PIA)                      the commercial viability, strategic importance and   Government  nancial support should also be linked to                                   However, the success of these initiatives will depend
               cover the cost of capital invested in it (Finance Division,   o ers important lessons. Before the transaction, the                           service-delivery requirements of each enterprise.  measurable outcomes, including return on invested                                        on implementation. Privatisation without competition,
               2025).                                                                                                                                                                                        capital, EVA, cost recovery and operational e ciency. A
                                                                government absorbed more than Rs.670 billion in                                             A transparent project-selection process, appropriate   performance-linked funding framework would help                                      PPPs without e ective risk allocation, and state
               Nevertheless, recent  gures suggest some marginal   liabilities and debt, transferring a substantial part of                                 risk allocation, competitive bidding and e ective   ensure that public resources support restructuring and                                  ownership without professional governance will o er
               improvement. During the  rst half of FY2026,     the historical  nancial burden to taxpayers (Daily                                          contract monitoring will be essential to ensure that   measurable improvements  rather  than  perpetuating                                  limited improvements. A coordinated  approach
               pro table SOEs generated gains of Rs. 423.3 billion,   Times, 2026).  This highlights the importance of                                      PPPs deliver value rather than create new contingent   recurring losses (The Nation, 2025).                                                 combining  nancial discipline, independent oversight,
               while loss-making entities recorded losses of Rs. 342.8   addressing legacy liabilities, operational ine ciencies                            liabilities for the government.                                                                                                             operational   restructuring  and    transparent
               billion. This resulted in a narrow net adjusted pro t of   and governance weaknesses before transferring                                     Governance: The Foundation of                    In the energy sector, reducing circular debt requires                                      public-service funding is essential.
               Rs.  80.5  billion  for  the  sector.  Consequently,  the  net   ownership.                                                                  Sustainable Reform                               sustained attention to cost recovery, operational                                          Ultimately, the performance of Pakistan's SOEs should
                scal  ow to the government—representing the     The objective should not simply be to sell an enterprise                                                                                     e ciency, metering infrastructure and improved                                             be measured not by their size or the scale of
               di erence  between   SOE   contributions  and    but to establish a commercially viable business                                             Ownership changes and private-sector participation    nancial settlements between distribution companies                                    government support they receive, but by their
               government support—stood at approximately Rs. 35.8   operating under transparent rules and genuine                                           cannot deliver lasting results without e ective   and   power   producers.  Temporary   nancial                                             contribution to productivity, service delivery,  scal
               billion as per H1-FY2026 report.                 competition.                                                                                governance. The SOE Act, 2023 and Ownership and   arrangements alone cannot resolve the structural                                          sustainability and national economic value.
                                                                                                                                                                                                             weaknesses responsible for recurring liabilities.
                                                                                                                                                            Management Policy, 2023 provide a framework for

               48   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58