Page 51 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 51

A r t ic les  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                            Privatisation: Initiated in the early 1990s, the programme   5.  Financial  Discipline: Performance-based support
                                                                                                                                                                                      cement
                                                                                                                                                                                                      and
                                                                                                                                                                       several
                                                                                                                                                                               banks,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 instead of automatic bailouts.
                                                                                                                                                            transferred
                                                                                                                                                                                               plants
              Who Should Own and Run Pakistan’s SOEs?                                                                                                       telecommunications businesses to private ownership.   6.  Fair Competition: Equal operating conditions for
                                                                                                                                                            However, some transactions faced political opposition,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 public and private enterprises.
                                A Case for Strategic Reform                                                                                                 litigation and procedural challenges.            The Human Side of Reform
                                                                                                                                                            Governance Reforms:  The SOE Ownership and
                                                                                                                                                            Governance  Policy  and  the State-Owned Enterprises   SOE reforms must protect the legitimate interests of
                                                                                                                                                            (Governance and Operations) Act, 2023, aim to    employees and their families. Restructuring and
                                                                                                                                                            strengthen professional management, transparency and   privatisation should include fair compensation, voluntary
               Introduction                                     weak bill recovery. These                                                                   accountability. The Finance Division's Central Monitoring   separation  schemes,  retraining  opportunities,
               Every  citizen  of  Pakistan  contributes to  the   nancial   ine ciencies contribute                                                        Unit also monitors SOE performance.              redeployment and protection of pension rights.
                                                                to the accumulation of
               burden of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), whether they   circular debt, creating                                                             IMF Programmes: IMF-supported programmes have    Making Privatisation Work
               use their services or not. The cost of ine cient electricity   signi cant pressure on                                                        encouraged  scal discipline and SOE restructuring.   Successful privatisation requires transparent valuations,
               distribution is re ected in power bills, while taxpayers   the economy.                                                                      However, sustainable reform requires continued national   competitive bidding, resolution of legal and  nancial
               bear the losses of airlines, railways and manufacturing                                                                                      commitment beyond external programme conditions.  liabilities, e ective regulation and protection of public
               units through subsidies and government grants.   Pakistan Railways:                                                                          PIA Privatisation: The privatisation process involving PIA   interests. Proceeds should be directed towards debt
               Borrowing to  nance these losses further increases public   Ageing  infrastructure,                                                          represents an important test of the government's reform   reduction and productive investment rather than routine
               debt, passing the  nancial burden on to future   operational  weaknesses                                                                     agenda.  Its  outcome  should  be  assessed  through   expenditure.
               generations.                                     and substantial pension
                                                                obligations continue to                                                                     improved operations, service quality and economic value.  The Role of Accountants, Auditors and Professionals
               SOEs were established to serve the public interest,   a ect  its   nancial                                                                   Rethinking State Ownership: A
               support strategic industries and provide essential   sustainability.                                                                                                                          Accountants, auditors and  nancial professionals can
               services. However, many have become a recurring burden                   Adnan Mehmood Khan                                                  Practical Framework                              support SOE reforms through reliable  nancial reporting,
               on the national economy.  The critical question for   Pakistan Steel Mills: The   Senior Manager, Quality                                    The fundamental question for policymakers is: Why does   stronger  internal  controls,  independent  audits,
               Pakistan is no longer whether SOEs need reform, but   largely inactive enterprise   Assurance Department                                     the state own a particular enterprise, and is  public   performance evaluation, cost management and
               which businesses the state should own and how those   continues  to  carry  Institute of Chartered                                           ownership still necessary?                       professional board oversight.
               retained under public ownership can be managed   signi cant liabilities and   Accountants of Pakistan (ICAP)                                                                                  From Burden to Value: A Vision for
               e ciently and sustainably.                       associated costs despite                                                                    SOEs can be classi ed into three groups:         2030
               Why the State Entered Business                   years of limited operations.                                                                Group 1: Businesses the State Does Not Need to Own
                                                                The problem is not equally distributed across all SOEs. A                                   Commercial enterprises operating in competitive   By 2030, Pakistan's SOE reforms should aim to achieve:
               At independence in 1947,  Pakistan's  private sector had   relatively small group accounts for a substantial share of                        markets, such as hotels, trading companies and certain   •  State withdrawal from businesses that do not require
               limited capital and industrial capacity. The state therefore   the  nancial burden, which the federal government                             manufacturing businesses, should be considered for   public ownership.
               assumed an active role in establishing industries, banks,   continues to absorb through subsidies, grants and                                privatisation, restructuring or closure where they are no
               airlines and utilities to support economic development   guarantees. Every rupee spent covering avoidable losses                             longer viable.                                   •  Performance-based management and reduced losses
               and  ll gaps in private investment.              reduces the  scal space available for essential priorities                                  Group 2: Strategic Enterprises and Essential Services  in electricity distribution companies.
               The nationalisation policies of the 1970s further   such as education, healthcare and infrastructure.                                                                                         •  Professional boards, measurable targets and timely
               expanded government ownership across banking,    Why Do SOEs Fail?                                                                           Enterprises operating in electricity distribution, railways,   audited accounts across retained SOEs.
               insurance and manufacturing. The underlying rationale                                                                                        ports and gas infrastructure may require public oversight   •  Transparent subsidies reaching their intended
               was that state ownership would protect strategic sectors,   The recurring losses of SOEs re ect several institutional                        but not necessarily direct government management.   bene ciaries.
               strengthen economic self-reliance and ensure that the   and operational weaknesses:                                                          Private  management    contracts,  public-private
               bene ts of industrial development reached the wider   1.  Unclear Objectives: Con icting commercial and                                      partnerships,  corporate  restructuring  and  independent   •  Redirection of public resources towards education,
               population.                                          public-service  responsibilities  without  clearly                                      regulation can improve their performance.           healthcare and infrastructure.
               Some of these initiatives initially achieved considerable   de ned priorities and measurable targets.                                        Group 3: Enterprises with a Public-Service Mandate  •  Financially sustainable SOEs contributing dividends to
               success. Pakistan International Airlines (PIA), for example,   2. Political   Interference:  Politically  in uenced                          SOEs serving remote and underserved communities may   the national treasury.
               once  enjoyed  international  recognition,  while Pakistan   appointments,  recruitment  and  operational                                    remain  state-owned,  provided  their  public-service   Conclusion
               Steel Mills represented the country's industrial ambitions.   decisions that undermine merit and accountability.                             obligations are clearly de ned, adequately funded and
               Over time, however, political interference, weak   3.  Weak  Corporate   Governance:   Frequent                                              regularly evaluated.  Subsidies  for  a ordable  services   SOEs become a  scal burden when they lack clear
               governance and operational ine ciencies undermined   management changes, limited board independence                                          should be transparently allocated through the    objectives, sound governance and  nancial discipline.
               the performance of several enterprises.  Their original                                                                                      government budget.                               Their economic contribution depends on appropriate
               strategic purpose increasingly became overshadowed by   and unclear responsibilities.                                                        What Good State Ownership Looks                  ownership structures, professional management and
               recurring  nancial losses.                       4.  Dependence    on    Government    Bailouts:                                             Like?                                            accountability. Pakistan must distinguish between
                                                                                                                                                                                                             enterprises requiring public ownership and those better
               The Size of the Problem                              Expectations of  nancial assistance that weaken                                         Where public  ownership  remains  necessary,  the   suited to private investment, while ensuring that retained
                                                                    incentives for  nancial discipline.
               Pakistan has more than 200 SOEs operating across energy,   5.  Lack  of Transparency: Delayed  nancial reporting                             government should act as a professional shareholder by   SOEs operate e ciently and ful l their mandates.
               transport,  nance, manufacturing, trading and services.   and  inadequate  disclosure  of  institutional                                     ensuring:                                        Reducing avoidable losses will release public resources
               While  some  perform  essential  public  functions,  many   performance.                                                                     1.  Separation  of  Roles:  Distinct  ownership,  for essential services and national development.
               commercial enterprises are expected to generate                                                                                                 policymaking and regulatory functions.
               su cient revenue to sustain their operations.  Yet a   6.  Oversta ng and Outdated Systems: Ine cient
               number continue to incur substantial losses.         sta ng structures, obsolete technology and limited                                      2.  Independent Boards: Merit-based appointments
               The  nancial burden is particularly visible in the following   investment in modern skills.                                                     and professional oversight.
               areas:                                           What Has Been Tried So Far?                                                                 3. Performance  Targets:  Measurable   nancial,
                                                                                                                                                               operational and service-delivery indicators.
               Power sector: Electricity distribution companies face   Pakistan has introduced several initiatives to address SOE
               technical and commercial losses, electricity  theft and   ine ciencies, although implementation remains uneven.                              4.  Financial  Transparency:  Timely publication of
                                                                                                                                                               audited  nancial statements.

               46   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55   56