Page 65 - CMA Journal (Sep-Oct 2026)
P. 65

A r t ic les  S ec t ion



                                                                                                                                                           When the liquidator approached FBR for the required   Public-Sector Governance and                                                          Under Section 418 of the Companies Act, 2017, the   90–120 days, a legally de ned deemed-clearance
               Making Corporate Exit Easier: Reforming                                                                                                     authorisation letter, o cials directed the application   Compliance Risks                                                                   liquidator convenes the  nal meeting to present the   mechanism could apply, subject to appropriate
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        nal accounts and report. However, SECP does not
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         safeguards and clearly speci ed exceptions.
                                                                                                                                                           through the Iris online system. However, the necessary
                         Company Liquidation in Pakistan                                                                                                   form was unavailable on the platform.             The challenges can be particularly acute for unlisted                                     provide a standardised  statutory template  for the   Standardise the Section 359 Review Process
                                                                                                                                                                                                             public companies associated with banks, institutional
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Liquidator’s Final Report, potentially  leading  to
                                                                                                                                                           Repeated visits and meetings with tax o cials,
                                                                                                                                                           including senior commissioners, failed to resolve the   shareholders, or nominee directors.                                                 inconsistent assessments across company registration   SECP should publish a clear scrutiny checklist,
                                                                                                                                                           issue promptly. Although the matter was referred to   Unlike some private-sector environments where                                         o ces.                                            prescribe a standard template for the Liquidator’s Final
                                                                                                                                                           the relevant Inland Revenue members, the response   informal practices may in uence administrative                                                                                            Report, and establish binding timelines for reviewing
               Pakistan has made progress in simplifying company   di culties,    and                                                                      indicated that uploading the form would take time.  processes, public-sector entities and regulated                                         Section 359 introduces further uncertainty. After   and registering  nal documents. A 30-day review
               incorporation  through  electronic  registration.  uncertainty surrounding                                                                                                                    institutions operate under scrutiny from investigative                                    receiving the  nal report and audited accounts, SECP   target could improve predictability.
               However, the liquidation of a solvent company remains   the   nal  dissolution                                                              Intervention by the Federal Tax Ombudsman         bodies, including the Federal Investigation Agency                                        scrutinises the documents and determines whether to
               lengthy, costly, and procedurally complex.       process.                                                                                   After prolonged delays, the liquidator approached the   (FIA) and the National Accountability Bureau (NAB).                                 register them. The company is deemed dissolved after   Protect Liquidator Remuneration and Provide
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       90 days from registration.
               Only  around  10–40  local  companies  reportedly   Limited                                                                                 Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO). Following the hearing,   Shareholders  also  approached  the  Federal                                                                                            Indemnity
               undergo formal winding up annually, while many                                                                                              FBR was directed to issue the letter manually.    Ombudsman over delays in releasing funds. However,                                        However, the  absence of publicly available,      Clarify the rules governing liquidators’ remuneration
               others use simpli ed exit mechanisms. Businesses   Availability of                                                                          However, the letter did not adequately establish the   unauthorised shortcuts or premature distributions                                    transparent scrutiny benchmarks leaves liquidators   and monthly allowances, including appropriate
               often avoid formal liquidation because of limited   Professional                                                                             nal tax demand or fully satisfy the legal requirement.   could expose both the liquidator and individual                                   uncertain about acceptance criteria, registration   in ation adjustments for prolonged assignments.
               professional  expertise,  complex  compliance    Liquidators                                                                                As shareholders continued to demand the release of   directors to regulatory and legal consequences.                                        timelines, and the possibility of repeated queries.  Provide clear guidance on indemnity arrangements
               requirements, and delays involving the Securities and                                                                                       funds, the  liquidator sought professional advice and   The liquidator therefore had to act as a safeguard                                  In  this case,  the  nal  accounts  were  expected  to  be   and the protection of professionals acting in good faith
               Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) and the   Before appointing an                                                                       assessed the amount that could be distributed without   against decisions that could compromise statutory                                   closed in the  rst week of July 2026, with the  nal   while complying with statutory requirements.
               Federal Board of Revenue (FBR).                  individual liquidator, the   Muhammad Umair Bhaur,                                         compromising potential tax payments.              compliance, despite pressure to accelerate the process.                                   EOGM    scheduled   for  mid-September   2026.
                                                                directors  approached                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Establish Dedicated Corporate Dissolution Desks
               Although the Companies Act, 2017 envisages the   several leading audit           ACMA                                                       The liquidator subsequently issued three letters to FBR,   Maintaining Compliance During                                                    Nevertheless, the ultimate dissolution date remained
               completion of Members’ Voluntary Winding Up within                                                                                          explaining that the delay resulted from the absence of                                                                                      unpredictable.                                    Create specialised  liquidation  units  within FBR
               one year, the process can take several years in practice.    rms, but none accepted the assignment.                                         an appropriate facility on the department’s system.   Prolonged Liquidation                                                                                                                   Regional Tax O ces and SECP Company Registration
               These delays  lock up  capital,  increase  administrative   The  rms reportedly cited unlimited statutory liability,                        With no substantive response, the paid-up capital was   While awaiting FBR’s authorisation, the liquidator                                  Unmitigated Personal Risk                         O ces to handle solvent voluntary liquidations
               costs, and undermine investor con dence.         uncertain timelines, and reputational risks. Some                                          distributed to identi ed shareholders, while unclaimed   continued to comply with Section 415 of the                                        Individual liquidators may face unforeseen regulatory   separately from insolvency cases. Dedicated personnel
                                                                o ered consultancy services instead, leaving the                                           amounts were deposited with the State Bank of     Companies Act, 2017.                                                                      objections, penalties,  legal costs, and  post-closure   could improve coordination, technical guidance, and
               Formal Liquidation and Simpli ed Exit            appointed liquidator responsible for statutory                                             Pakistan (SBP) under the prescribed procedure.                                                                                              administrative expenses without the  nancial      accountability.
               Mechanisms                                       compliance.                                                                                The retained earnings remained in the company’s bank   This involved:                                                                       resources available to institutional  rms. Once
               Part X of the Companies Act, 2017, beginning with   An individual professional accountant was eventually                                    account until the required authorisation was received.   •  Preparing  semi-annual   nancial  statements  and                               company funds have been distributed to shareholders   Conclusion: A Predictable Exit
                                                                                                                                                                                                                obtaining independent statutory audits.
               Section 293, provides the legal framework for winding   appointed.  The  process  began  with  the  Board’s                                 A third-party escrow arrangement was not available as                                                                                       or  deposited  with  SBP,  the  liquidator  may  be  left   Framework is Essential for Investment
               up companies through court-supervised, voluntary,   Declaration of Solvency, a special resolution of the                                    an alternative for holding the liquidation funds.  •  Preparing interim liquidator reports.                                                 personally exposed.                               A business environment that makes incorporation easy
               and court-supervised voluntary procedures.       members, and the appointment of a quali ed                                                 Personal Liability, Remuneration and               • Convening  biannual   Extraordinary  General                                           To reduce this risk, individual liquidators should seek   but liquidation di cult can leave capital trapped in
               For a solvent  company whose shareholders wish  to   liquidator with agreed remuneration. Statutory notices                                 Shareholder Pressure                                 Meetings (EOGMs) to present audited accounts and                                       formal indemnity resolutions approved  at the  nal   dormant companies, increase compliance costs, and
               avoid court proceedings, Members’ Voluntary Winding   were subsequently published in national English- and                                                                                       reports to members.                                                                    EOGM and maintain comprehensive records of all    expose professional liquidators to disproportionate
               Up  is  generally  a  suitable  option.  However,  the   Urdu-language newspapers and the O cial Gazette.                                   The prolonged process placed disproportionate      •  Submitting meeting minutes, accounts, and reports                                     correspondence until SECP’s registration of the  nal   risks.
               practical experience of an unlisted public limited   Upon  appointment,  the  liquidator  assumed                                           responsibility on the individual liquidator. While audit   to SECP.                                                                         documents is con rmed.
               company demonstrates that even a straightforward   responsibility for the company’s assets, liabilities,                                     rms could have provided institutional support, they                                                                                                                                          Pakistan should  streamline its corporate  exit
               liquidation  can encounter  signi cant  regulatory   statutory  lings, and distribution of surplus funds.                                   were not willing to assume the statutory role     After sustained e orts, FBR issued another manual                                         Policy Recommendations for Faster                 framework through digital integration, time-bound tax
               obstacles.                                                                                                                                                                                    authorisation  letter at  the  end  of May  2025.  The                                    Corporate Exit                                    clearance, transparent SECP scrutiny, and stronger
                                                                However, progress stalled when SECP  lings required                                        themselves.                                       liquidation had commenced in late March 2022,                                                                                               safeguards for liquidators.
               Case Study: A Four-Year Liquidation              compliance with Section 141 of the applicable tax law.                                     As the assignment extended beyond expectations,   meaning that  more  than  three  years  had  elapsed                                      Pakistan needs a more predictable, transparent, and
               Process                                          FBR IRIS System: A Major Compliance                                                        shareholders increasingly questioned the liquidator’s   before this critical requirement was resolved.                                      e cient corporate dissolution framework.  The     E cient  liquidation would release capital  for
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         productive investment, reduce disputes among
               The company examined in this case study could not   Bottleneck                                                                              monthly allowance and perceived delays as being in   Following receipt of the authorisation, the members                                    following reforms could help reduce delays and    shareholders and directors, improve regulatory
                                                                                                                                                           his personal  nancial interest. In reality, the principal
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       protect all parties involved.
               obtain the regulatory licence required to conduct its   Absence of an Appropriate Online Form                                               obstacles were external regulatory requirements   approved the distribution of a portion of  retained                                                                                         accountability, and strengthen investor con dence. A
               principal business, as speci ed in its memorandum of                                                                                        beyond his control.                               earnings and the reservation of funds for liquidation                                     Integrate SECP and FBR Digital Systems            business-friendly economy requires not only an
               association. Following the regulator’s refusal on   Section 141 required the liquidator to notify the Tax                                                                                     expenses.  Dividends  were   distributed  after                                           Develop application programming interface (API)   e cient process for starting a company, but also a
               technical grounds, continuing operations became   Commissioner within 14 days of appointment or                                             The liquidator also faced  nancial pressure because   withholding applicable  income tax,  while  amounts                                                                                     clear, fair, and timely mechanism for closing one.
               impractical.                                     taking control of the company’s assets.  The tax                                           the monthly allowance was not necessarily adjusted   relating to unidenti able shareholders were deposited                                  integration between SECP eServices and FBR Iris to
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       facilitate  tax noti cations,  authorisations,  and status
                                                                                                                                                                                                             with SBP in accordance with the prescribed procedure.
               The company had negligible  xed assets, while its   authority was allowed 90 days to determine                                              for in ation. Meanwhile, directors and shareholders                                                                                         tracking.
               paid-up capital and accumulated investment earnings   outstanding tax liabilities and inform the liquidator of                              sought rapid closure without always appreciating the   Final Dissolution: Uncertainty Under
               were held in bank accounts. Given its straightforward   the amount to be reserved before any distribution to                                legal consequences of premature distributions  or   Section 359                                                                             Introduce     Statutory     Deemed-Clearance
                nancial position, liquidation was initially expected to   shareholders or creditors.                                                       non-compliance.                                                                                                                             Mechanisms
               take less than a year.                           The liquidator could also face personal responsibility                                     These circumstances created friction between the   Even after settling tax demands and distributing                                         Establish a binding timeline for FBR to determine tax
               Instead, the process extended beyond four years,   for a shortfall if funds were distributed without                                        liquidator and the board, even though the liquidator   surplus assets, the  nal dissolution stage presents                                  liabilities under Section 141. For example, if the tax
               primarily because of regulatory delays, tax-clearance   meeting the statutory requirements.                                                 was legally responsible for ensuring compliance.  further challenges.                                                                       authority fails to communicate its assessment within

               60   ICMA’s Chartered Management Accountant, Sep-Oct 2026
   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67   68   69   70